Blood found on Kidus Yohannes’ shoes became a key piece of a murder prosecution that took years to reach trial.
SALT LAKE CITY, Utah — Blood recovered from a suspect’s shoes after a 2018 killing became a key piece of evidence in a case that would take years to reach a jury and ultimately send Kidus Chane Yohannes to prison for life without the possibility of parole.
Third District Judge Kristine Johnson imposed the life sentence Sept. 29 after an August jury convicted Yohannes, 39, of first-degree aggravated murder in the death of 20-year-old Candace Samples. He also received zero to five years in prison for attempted manslaughter in the stabbing of Jeffrey Plante, who survived. The result capped a prosecution in which evidence gathered near the beginning of the investigation remained central even though laboratory work and court proceedings stretched across much of the next eight years.
The blood evidence emerged after police located Yohannes following the Nov. 7, 2018, attack. Prosecutors said Yohannes denied any role in the stabbings and denied having knowledge of or interaction with the victims. Investigators nevertheless collected his shoes because they appeared to have blood on them. Forensic analysis was delayed, according to the district attorney, but testing eventually found that the blood matched Samples’ DNA profile. That result strengthened the physical link between Yohannes and the woman who had been killed.
Investigators had another independent source of evidence from a business near the crime scene. Surveillance footage from a 7-Eleven showed Yohannes and Samples entering and leaving the store together before the attack, prosecutors said. The footage was important because Yohannes had denied interacting with the victims when questioned. It did not by itself show the entire fatal encounter, but prosecutors presented it as part of the larger chain of evidence connecting the people involved before witnesses described what happened inside the dumpster enclosure behind a nearby Dollar Tree.
The witness accounts supplied the sequence that cameras and laboratory testing could not. Authorities said Samples had taken Yohannes’ cellphone earlier at the Marmalade Branch Library. Yohannes later confronted her and another man in the enclosure behind the Dollar Tree at 477 N. 300 West. Prosecutors said he pulled out a knife and threatened to use it if he did not get his phone back. A witness saw the confrontation and left to summon help from the nearby 7-Eleven.
Jeffrey Plante was the person who responded. After being told what was happening, he ran toward the enclosure and entered in an effort to help, according to prosecutors. Yohannes stabbed Plante, who survived. Another person in the enclosure climbed over a wall to escape and then returned with a large board. That witness saw Yohannes attacking Samples, prosecutors said. Someone opened the gates, and Yohannes fled. Samples and Plante were taken to a hospital, where Samples died from her injuries.
The combination of witness testimony, surveillance and physical evidence gave investigators several ways to reconstruct the attack, but the case did not immediately become a prosecution. Forensic work took years to mature into the result authorities later highlighted. When Salt Lake City police arrested Yohannes in 2021, officials said the homicide investigation had remained active despite the passage of time. The district attorney filed first-degree aggravated murder and first-degree attempted murder charges in July of that year.
The interval between evidence collection and arrest illustrates how the laboratory process affected the case. Police had possessed the relevant footwear since the early investigation, but the DNA findings that prosecutors ultimately relied on were not available at once. Salt Lake City police said when announcing the 2021 arrest that homicide cases can be lengthy and complex. Prosecutors later said the biological evidence went through multiple levels of testing before the case was presented to the jury.
Even after charges were filed, the case required several more years before trial. The Salt Lake County District Attorney’s Office said delays involved DNA testing, competency evaluations and witness availability. Those factors pushed the start of trial to Aug. 4, 2026. Proceedings concluded Aug. 7 with an aggravated-murder conviction in Samples’ death. Prosecutors thanked police detectives for their work with DNA technology and said the biological evidence helped make the case strong enough to secure a verdict.
The count involving Plante produced a different result from the charge prosecutors initially filed. Yohannes had faced attempted murder for that stabbing. Jurors made a finding involving imperfect self-defense, which led to an attempted-manslaughter conviction. At sentencing, Johnson imposed a prison term of zero to five years for that offense. The aggravated-murder verdict in Samples’ death carried far more severe consequences: life in prison without the possibility of parole.
The evidence-focused history of the case did not define the entire sentencing hearing. When Yohannes returned to court in September, Samples’ loved ones spoke about the person they had lost. The couple who raised her described watching her grow up, the happiness she brought to their home and difficulties she experienced, according to reports of the hearing. They also described how her absence continued to affect them. A video prepared by her loved ones and focused on her life was shown in the courtroom.
Plante addressed the judge as well. Years after surviving the stabbing, he spoke about changes he had made in his life and work he was doing to help others. His presence gave the court a direct link to the confrontation reconstructed through the prosecution’s evidence. The physical exhibits and witness accounts had explained how the attack unfolded; Plante’s remarks showed that its consequences remained present for one of the people who survived it.
The case also highlights the difference between an investigative lead and evidence ultimately accepted through the criminal process. Police suspected Yohannes early enough to question him and seize his shoes, yet prosecutors did not obtain a conviction until 2026. Between those points came laboratory analysis, the filing of charges, competency proceedings, witness issues and a jury trial. The passage of time did not change what investigators had collected, but it affected when that material could be used to support a completed prosecution.
Salt Lake County District Attorney Sim Gill emphasized that process after the verdict. He said Samples’ parents had remained engaged from the beginning and thanked them for their patience while biological evidence underwent repeated testing. The statement also credited prosecutors, support staff, victim counselors and Salt Lake City police detectives. After sentencing, Gill said the office hoped the family had received a measure of justice, while acknowledging that a prison sentence could not restore Samples’ life.
The final judgment now rests on more than the forensic result that helped propel the case forward. Jurors also had the accounts of witnesses, the circumstances of the cellphone confrontation, surveillance information and other evidence developed through the investigation. Together, those elements produced the aggravated-murder verdict that Johnson used as the basis for a sentence carrying no possibility of parole. The attempted-manslaughter conviction separately accounted for the injuries to Plante.
Currently, Yohannes remains sentenced to life without parole for Samples’ murder, with an additional zero-to-five-year term for Plante’s stabbing. The case that began with evidence collected at a Salt Lake City crime scene in 2018 has passed through conviction and sentencing, leaving the DNA findings as one part of a broader record that ultimately reached a jury eight years later.
Author note: Last updated November 18, 2026.