Texas man killed girlfriend then made admissions to his ex-girlfriend

Court records trace Jeffrey Lee Devorah’s case from a 2023 murder filing to an August conviction and September life sentence.

JOURDANTON, Texas — The murder case against Jeffrey Lee Devorah spent years moving through Atascosa County court calendars before a jury convicted him in August and a judge sentenced him to life in prison for killing Tiffany Lynette Garza.

The final court sequence was comparatively short. Devorah, 47, went to trial in August 2026 on a murder charge filed three years earlier. Jurors found him guilty Aug. 13. He then chose to have a judge determine punishment, and Judge Russell Wilson imposed a life sentence in late September. The sentence requires Devorah to serve 30 years before he can be considered for parole. Those dates close the trial-level arc of a case that began not with an arrest, but with Garza’s disappearance in 2019 and a search that uncovered blood evidence and burned human remains.

Garza, 37, was last seen March 25, 2019, in the Poteet area. Her mother, Lilly Morua, reported her missing to the Atascosa County Sheriff’s Office on April 26. Investigators later said they believed Garza was killed sometime between March 28 and April 4. At that stage, no murder prosecution existed, no defendant had been charged and authorities had not publicly established what had happened to her. The case changed months later when investigators received information that led them to a residence on Bocawood Drive north of Poteet.

In July 2019, sheriff’s investigators and Texas Rangers searched that property for three days. Authorities said a witness had reported seeing Garza’s killing and helping burn her body in Devorah’s backyard. Inside the house, investigators found what they described as significant blood evidence. Behind the home, teams sifted through a burn pit for two days and recovered human bones and bone fragments. The evidence turned the investigation from a missing-person inquiry into a case with a physical scene, potential human remains and a witness account pointing to homicide.

Forensic analysis added detail but also revealed limits. Experts connected to Texas State University’s Forensic Anthropology Center recovered 14 human bone fragments and concluded they came from a female between 22 and 56 years old. Garza’s age fit that range. Earlier reporting from the sheriff’s office said the burned fragments did not produce usable DNA. The genetic identification came instead from blood collected inside the residence, where testing by the Bexar County Crime Lab linked one sample to Garza’s family line. Authorities said another blood sample belonged to Devorah.

Devorah acknowledged one important fact when investigators interviewed him in 2019: Garza had been living at the Bocawood Drive home. He denied knowing what had happened to her. Prosecutors later said Devorah made admissions to a former girlfriend that were consistent with the physical evidence and witness statements. Public sentencing reports do not reproduce those statements in full, and the material reviewed for this report does not include a released cause of death. Those limits are significant because they separate what has been publicly documented from details that may have been presented at trial but are not available in the published record.

The arrest came much later. San Antonio police took Devorah into custody on March 15, 2023, nearly four years after Garza disappeared. He was charged with murder and held on a $500,000 bond. Atascosa County court records show the case was filed in June 2023 as docket number 23-06-0162-CRA. Once filed, it began a long pretrial path. The case appeared on county trial dockets in 2024 and again in 2026, showing that the prosecution remained active even as trial settings changed over time.

By summer 2026, the case was approaching a jury. A July docket listed Devorah’s murder case for an Aug. 10 trial setting, with attorney Adrian Perez shown as defense counsel. The August criminal trial docket again listed the same murder case. After trial began, jurors returned a guilty verdict on Aug. 13, according to the district attorney’s office and local reports. The verdict resolved the factual question jurors had been asked to decide: whether the state had proved beyond a reasonable doubt that Devorah murdered Garza.

The punishment phase took a different route because Devorah elected to have a judge sentence him. A Sept. 29 Atascosa County criminal docket listed his case for sentencing. Judge Wilson then imposed the life term. The sentence carries a minimum of 30 years before parole eligibility, according to authorities. That does not promise release after three decades; it marks the earliest point at which parole consideration can occur. Until then, the sentence keeps Devorah in state custody unless a court later changes the judgment through an appeal or other post-conviction process.

The legal timeline is only one way to understand the case. Garza’s relatives experienced the same years differently: first as a disappearance, then as an investigation involving human remains, later as a murder prosecution and finally as a trial. Family members and close friends attended the sentencing. Their presence underscored the gap between the efficiency of a docket entry — a date, case number and setting — and the much longer personal period they described as years of uncertainty and loss.

After sentencing, District Attorney Audrey Gossett Louis said the punishment could not return what Garza’s family had lost. Her office credited the work of law enforcement, forensic experts, prosecutors and jurors. That public statement also emphasized Garza herself, a point echoed by relatives who later spoke to KSAT. They described her as funny, caring and central to family life, with memories built around cooking, singing, jokes, children and gatherings rather than the crime-scene details that came to dominate public coverage of her death.

Natalie Garza said Tiffany had been looking forward to becoming a grandmother when they last saw each other. Natalie was pregnant at the time, and her daughter was 7 by the time the case ended in a life sentence. Other relatives spoke about events Tiffany missed and the everyday family experiences that could not be recovered. Patricia Jaime, Garza’s former partner, also raised the continuing pain of not having all of Garza’s remains. The sentence answered criminal responsibility, but family members said it could not answer every question they carried from the years before trial.

The evidence described publicly helps explain why the case could move forward despite those unresolved points. Investigators had a witness who directed them to the property and described what had happened. They had blood evidence from inside the residence, including a sample linked to Garza’s family. They had human bone fragments from a backyard burn area that forensic experts determined came from a woman in Garza’s age range. Prosecutors also said Devorah made statements to a former girlfriend that fit the physical and testimonial evidence. The jury ultimately accepted the state’s case and convicted him.

The path from disappearance to judgment was therefore not a single continuous proceeding. It unfolded in distinct phases: a 2019 missing-person report, a July search and forensic work, years of continued investigation, a 2023 arrest and murder filing, a prolonged pretrial period, an August 2026 conviction and a September sentence. Looking at the case through that sequence shows how much of the work occurred before the courtroom phase that produced the final judgment.

From a court-record perspective, the case has reached its decisive endpoint: the 2023 murder charge produced an August 2026 conviction, followed by a life sentence weeks later. Any future litigation would occur after judgment rather than as part of the trial itself, while the existing sentence requires Devorah to serve 30 years before he can first be considered for parole.

Author note: Last updated Nov. 16, 2026.