Storage facility manager confronts mother and teenage daughter before shots erupt in Florida

Kandice Jo Pierce was already wanted in an unrelated arson case when authorities say a Palm Bay storage dispute escalated into gunfire.

PALM BAY, Fla. — When investigators began identifying two people seen leaving a Palm Bay storage facility after its manager was shot, one of the women was already familiar to law enforcement from an unrelated investigation and an earlier effort to help her find housing.

That overlap helped authorities build the case against Kandice Jo Pierce, 40, who is accused of shooting the manager after being told that she and her 16-year-old daughter could not sleep inside a rented storage unit. Pierce was also the subject of an outstanding second-degree arson warrant from an unrelated Palm Bay case when the Oct. 10 shooting occurred, according to the sheriff’s office and subsequent reporting. The two investigations remain legally separate, but earlier police contacts gave detectives information they later used to identify Pierce and her daughter. Pierce has not been convicted of the shooting or the arson allegations.

The arson investigation came first. Public reporting based on investigative records says authorities had obtained a second-degree arson warrant for Pierce weeks before the storage shooting. The earlier case involved an allegation that a vehicle was deliberately set on fire at an automotive business in Palm Bay. During the investigation of that matter, an Indian Harbour Beach detective encountered Pierce and her daughter and spent time speaking with them. The contact included efforts to assist the pair in obtaining housing, according to records cited in reports about the later shooting. The detective also became familiar with their identities and appearance, information that would become relevant after another crime was reported.

On the morning of Oct. 10, a manager at the Public Storage property on Babcock Street was conducting rounds when she found two people who appeared to be sleeping or living inside one of the units. A probable cause affidavit says the manager told them that the storage space could not be used that way. Pierce, whose name was associated with the rental, responded that because she had rented the unit, she believed they should be allowed to stay. The manager offered to resolve the matter without reporting the violation: If the two occupants left, she would not notify management about finding them there.

Investigators say the manager then started to walk away. Rather than allowing the encounter to end, Pierce allegedly called the employee back. The manager told investigators that she heard a loud bang and felt pain in her face after turning her attention back toward the unit. Sheriff Wayne Ivey said two shots were fired. One struck the manager, while a second missed. The employee managed to flee from the immediate area and take cover, eventually calling 911 from beneath or behind a desk. Deputies responding to the scene found that she had suffered a small wound below an eye. A projectile remained in her face, authorities said, though the injury was initially described as non-life-threatening.

The account from Pierce’s daughter became one of the most consequential witness statements. Deputies found the 16-year-old at a gas station after she and her mother had left the storage property. According to the affidavit, the girl said Pierce became upset after the manager told them they could no longer sleep in the unit. She told investigators that her mother fired twice at the employee. The teenager’s statement directly addressed a question police could not answer simply from the rental records: Two people had been inside the unit, so identifying the renter did not automatically identify the shooter. The available reports do not indicate that the daughter was charged with firing a weapon.

Detectives also had physical evidence to compare with those accounts. Two spent .25-caliber shell casings were reportedly recovered outside the unit. Investigators documented an apparent bullet strike in a nearby storage space, supporting the assertion that two rounds had been fired. Surveillance footage showed two women leaving after the incident, and access information was tied to Pierce’s rental account. Reports based on investigative records said the women left the property carrying belongings. The scene and video evidence did not by themselves answer every question about who held the gun, but they helped establish the movements of the two occupants before officers located them.

The earlier detective’s familiarity with Pierce and her daughter then became useful. Investigators sent or showed images connected to the storage case to a law-enforcement officer who had met them before. That officer recognized Pierce and identified the younger woman as her daughter, according to reporting based on the case records. The connection is notable because the earlier encounter apparently had included an attempt to provide assistance rather than an arrest arising from the storage incident. Weeks later, the same familiarity helped detectives put names to people seen during an attempted-murder investigation. Authorities also recovered identification documents and used rental information as part of the identification process.

Once investigators said they were confident Pierce was the alleged shooter, Sheriff Ivey announced her name publicly and warned that she should be considered armed and dangerous. Pierce was not immediately found. Authorities said video later showed her at a RaceTrac convenience store on Palm Bay Road at about 1:30 p.m. that day. The sheriff’s office said agents were working with prosecutors on an attempted first-degree murder warrant while also noting that Pierce was already wanted in the separate arson case. Residents were told not to approach her. The search continued into the next morning, when Palm Bay officers located Pierce outside a business on Palm Bay Road and took her into custody without incident.

The shooting case then entered court with allegations more serious than the property dispute that preceded it. Local reporting said Pierce was charged with attempted first-degree premeditated murder and an offense involving shooting or throwing a missile into a building. The unrelated second-degree arson charge was also reflected in reporting about her custody status. A judge subsequently denied bond on the main shooting accusations. Being held without bond does not establish guilt; it determines pretrial custody while the criminal case proceeds. Prosecutors still must prove the allegations, and Pierce has the right to challenge the witnesses, physical evidence and assertions about her intent.

The underlying storage rule offers important context but only limited legal relevance to the violent-crime accusation. Florida law states that an individual self-storage space may not be used for residential purposes. The statute defines the facilities as places where tenants store and remove personal property. That means the manager was enforcing a rule grounded in state law when she told the occupants they could not sleep in the unit. Pierce’s position as the renter did not convert the space into a lawful residence. At the same time, a violation of that storage restriction is separate from the alleged act of firing a gun, and the prosecution’s attempted-murder case must be judged on evidence relating to the shooting itself.

The history of housing assistance also requires careful treatment. Investigators’ records indicate that a detective had previously tried to help Pierce and her daughter with housing, and authorities say the pair were later found sleeping in the storage unit. Those facts support the conclusion that housing was an issue in their circumstances, but the public record reviewed for this story does not establish the full cause or duration of their housing instability. It would be speculative to assign a motive for the alleged shooting beyond what witnesses reported. The daughter’s statement attributes Pierce’s anger to being told they had to leave, while the manager’s account describes an encounter that appeared to be winding down before the shots were fired.

The arson warrant also should not be used to fill gaps in the shooting case. Investigators have described the fire allegation as unrelated, even though the prior investigation helped officers recognize Pierce later. Evidence that Pierce was wanted on another charge does not prove she fired at the storage manager. Conversely, evidence gathered in the shooting investigation does not prove the separate arson accusation. The significance of the earlier case to the Oct. 10 events is largely chronological and investigative: Pierce was already being sought, a detective had previously encountered her and her daughter, and that prior knowledge helped authorities move from unidentified figures on surveillance footage to named subjects.

The manager survived, and authorities said her wound did not appear to be life-threatening. Public reports reviewed for this update do not provide a later detailed medical condition. Investigators have not publicly identified her in the coverage examined here. Restraining the description of her injury to the confirmed facts also avoids overstating the medical consequences while preserving the seriousness of an allegation in which a worker was struck by gunfire during routine duties.

By the morning after the shooting, the investigation had moved from an unidentified pair seen leaving the facility to Pierce’s arrest outside a Palm Bay business. Detectives had combined the manager’s account, the daughter’s statement, surveillance material, rental information and evidence recovered at the scene to identify her as the suspect. Pierce was then held on the shooting allegations while also facing the unrelated arson matter. The public reports reviewed for this update do not show that either case has reached a final judgment.

Author note: Last updated Nov. 20, 2026.