Stepmom joins search after killing stepdaughter with hammer before her Walmart shift

Investigators are still searching for the teenager’s remains while two men face charges tied to alleged efforts to conceal evidence.

ROBESON COUNTY, N.C. — Connie Graham has admitted killing her 18-year-old stepdaughter and begun a 20-to-25-year prison sentence, but the case of Sara Graham remains open in two important ways: her remains have not been found, and two other defendants still face prosecution.

The Sept. 30 guilty plea to second-degree murder settled the criminal case against Connie Graham without a trial and established that she killed Sara on Feb. 4, 2015. It did not answer where Sara was taken afterward or establish the guilt of Bobby Matthew McLellan and Luke Locklear, Graham’s sons, who were charged separately. Investigators are now pursuing those unresolved parts of a case that spent more than 11 years as a missing-person investigation. The latest verified reporting says search crews are concentrating on an area outside Fairmont while the two men remain under court supervision awaiting further proceedings.

The physical search has focused on the East White Pond Road area. On Sept. 16, weeks before Connie Graham’s plea, specialized crime-scene teams, divers and other personnel carried out an operation there. Sheriff Burnis Wilkins later confirmed that the activity was connected to Sara’s case and said evidence indicated her remains had been disposed of in that area in 2015. The effort has involved the Robeson County Sheriff’s Office, FBI, Robeson County Fire Marshal’s Office and anthropology specialists from North Carolina State University. Authorities have not announced a recovery or publicly disclosed all of the information that led investigators to the location.

Those searches matter because the charges against McLellan and Locklear concern what authorities allege happened after Sara was killed. A grand jury returned superseding indictments against the men in August. Prosecutors have alleged that McLellan helped remove Sara’s remains from the scene, dispose of them and conceal evidence. Locklear is accused of participating in the burning of items investigators believe were relevant to the killing. The two men have faced conspiracy and evidence-related charges, and accessory allegations were also added as the case moved forward. They have not pleaded guilty to killing Sara and have not been convicted of the pending offenses.

Their custody status also differs sharply from Connie Graham’s. Both men were initially jailed under $1 million bonds after the June arrests, but judges later reduced their bonds to $50,000. Locklear posted bond Aug. 31 and McLellan posted bond Sept. 2, according to court reporting. Both were placed on house arrest with specified exceptions, including work and certain approved activities. The latest published schedule reviewed for this story listed Dec. 7 as their next court date. Their mother’s guilty plea does not legally resolve the evidence against them, and prosecutors must establish each charge independently.

Connie Graham’s plea narrowed the issues by removing several allegations against her from future litigation. She had initially faced first-degree murder, felony conspiracy and a charge of altering, stealing or destroying criminal evidence. Under the agreement, she pleaded guilty to second-degree murder, while prosecutors dismissed the conspiracy and evidence charges against her. Judge Jason Disbrow imposed a minimum of 240 months and a maximum of 300 months in prison. Prosecutors said Sara’s family supported the agreement. The arrangement guaranteed a murder conviction and lengthy sentence while eliminating the need for relatives to go through a trial.

At the hearing, Graham admitted that she struck Sara in the head with a hammer after the two argued on the morning Sara disappeared. Prosecutors also described statements Graham allegedly made to jail inmates after she was arrested in June. According to the state’s account, she said she entered Sara’s room, turned on the light, woke her and became involved in an argument and shoving confrontation before striking her. Graham told the court she regretted what happened. That admission supplied a direct answer to how the confrontation became fatal, an answer investigators had not been able to make public during the decade when Sara remained listed as missing.

The evidence prosecutors described also placed new meaning on events from Feb. 4, 2015. Sara was supposed to work at a Walmart in Pembroke but never arrived. Her father, Hubert Graham, believed she had taken his white van after he returned home and found it missing. The van was later discovered near East McDonald Road. Witnesses said it had been driven toward the area with a silver BMW following it, according to the state’s courtroom presentation. Connie Graham owned a silver BMW. Prosecutors also said she bought cleaning supplies that morning and later burned Sara’s bed, acts they presented as part of the effort to conceal what happened.

At the time, Connie Graham was a deputy with the Robeson County Sheriff’s Office. She participated with family members in reporting Sara missing. The department terminated her employment weeks later, although officials in 2015 did not publicly state that the firing was connected to Sara’s disappearance. The FBI joined the investigation, and authorities continued pursuing leads without bringing charges for years. An FBI appeal in 2022 said investigators had followed hundreds of leads and interviewed dozens of people and believed Sara had not simply left voluntarily.

Renewed searches took place in 2023 and 2025, but the major legal breakthrough came in June 2026 after Sara was declared dead by a judge. Her biological mother had petitioned for the declaration following more than 11 years without verified evidence that Sara was alive. Wilkins said the ruling shifted the case formally from a missing-person investigation to a homicide investigation. Weeks later, Connie Graham, McLellan and Locklear were arrested. A grand jury then returned indictments, and Connie Graham remained jailed until resolving her case with the September plea.

For Sara’s family, the remaining search has significance beyond gathering evidence. Friend Sabrina Nickerson said after the plea that the conviction brought relief but also raised additional questions, especially because Sara had still not been recovered. Sara’s mother, Cathy Armenta, used the sentencing hearing to describe the pain of learning that Graham had concealed the truth while taking part in family gatherings after Sara disappeared. Wilkins said investigators remained committed to returning Sara to her relatives. That goal now stands apart from proving that Sara was killed, a fact established by Connie Graham’s conviction.

Authorities have not publicly said whether the information directing search teams toward East White Pond Road came from Connie Graham, either of her sons or another source. Wilkins told local reporters that investigators had received highly reliable information, but he declined to identify its origin. That uncertainty is important because the pending prosecutions concern alleged efforts to hide the crime, and any further statement or physical discovery could affect those cases. The absence of Sara’s remains also means investigators have not publicly announced a complete forensic account of what happened after the fatal confrontation inside the home.

As of Nov. 16, the public record therefore reflects a case divided into three different stages: Connie Graham has been convicted and sentenced; McLellan and Locklear remain accused defendants whose charges have not been proven; and the recovery operation continues without a publicly announced discovery of Sara’s remains. The murder plea answered the question that defined the investigation for 11 years, but the work of determining how the crime was concealed and bringing Sara home remains unfinished.

Author note: Last updated November 16, 2026.