Stepdad allegedly attacks 9-year-old girl as mother backs hit-and-run tale

Maya Thomas’ death shook a small South Jersey community after police said a reported hit-and-run concealed a far different sequence of events.

PAULSBORO, N.J. — Candles, balloons and memorial items became part of the landscape in Paulsboro after the death of 9-year-old Maya Thomas, giving residents a public place to grieve while investigators built a criminal case alleging that the danger came not from a fleeing driver, but from inside her home.

Maya died Oct. 13 after being taken to a hospital with severe injuries. Her mother, India Miller, 27, and stepfather, Sean Scott, 45, are charged with first-degree murder and related crimes. Authorities allege they assaulted the girl and then falsely suggested to police that she had been struck by a car while walking the family dog. The allegation transformed what initially appeared to be a traffic emergency into a homicide case that has since prompted court hearings, a child-welfare investigation and debate over homeschooling oversight.

The public learned of the allegations two days after Maya’s death, and hundreds of people later gathered at a vigil in Paulsboro. Local television reports showed residents joining a balloon release and leaving items in her memory. The gathering was striking in part because some people who came to mourn said they had not known Maya personally. The case confronted the community with an unsettling contrast: a child living in a residential neighborhood near a school and church, yet one whom many neighbors had rarely encountered.

That sense of distance has become part of the story because Maya was homeschooled. Local reporting said she lived near Loudenslager Elementary School but did not attend it. Her death later led some New Jersey lawmakers to discuss whether children educated at home should have more contact with people outside their households. The debate does not establish that school attendance would have prevented her death. Instead, it reflects a question raised by the allegations: how abuse can be detected when a child is less visible to teachers, nurses and other adults who might otherwise see changes in behavior or appearance.

Before any of those questions emerged, police were searching for a car. At about 1:10 a.m. Oct. 13, Scott called 911 after Maya was found unresponsive, authorities said. The couple gave investigators an account in which she had been outside with the dog and might have been struck by a vehicle. Miller reported hearing what sounded like screeching tires before Scott found Maya near a shed. Officers responded to that information by looking through the surrounding area for evidence of a crash or a driver who had left the scene.

Dispatch records later detailed the urgency of that effort. Officers sought surveillance footage from nearby properties, including a school and fire department, and checked for vehicles with signs of recent damage. But investigators say the expected evidence of a crash never appeared. Video did not show traffic matching the reported incident during the relevant period. At the hospital, medical staff were also telling police that Maya’s injuries were not consistent with a vehicle collision. The investigation began turning away from the roadway and toward the residence.

Authorities said Maya had extensive bruising and serious facial trauma. An autopsy later found multiple blunt-force injuries, including injuries in different stages of healing. The medical examiner ruled the death a homicide. The significance of the older injuries became clearer as prosecutors described their theory that Maya had been subjected to abuse over time. Those findings are central to the prosecution’s case, but the defendants retain the presumption of innocence and the state must prove its allegations in court.

Police said a search of the home produced additional evidence they considered important. Investigators reported finding wet children’s clothing with suspected blood in a bathroom and suspected blood on tile and cleaning equipment. Detectives also interviewed Maya’s 4-year-old sibling, who authorities said reported that Scott had struck Maya in the face and eyes. None of those allegations has yet been weighed by a trial jury. Together, however, authorities say they helped undermine the original account and supported charges against Miller and Scott.

Later court proceedings brought family history into public view. At Miller’s detention hearing, a prosecutor said relatives had described earlier alleged mistreatment of Maya and that one relative reported Miller acknowledged she and Scott struck the child before she lost consciousness. Prosecutors characterized the evidence as showing prolonged abuse. Miller’s lawyer, Justin Moore, countered with allegations that Scott had also been violent toward Miller and argued that her conduct and statements should be considered in light of that relationship.

The judge did not resolve those competing narratives at the detention hearing. Instead, Superior Court Judge Niki Arbittier decided that Miller should remain jailed while the case proceeds, citing the severity of the allegations and concerns about danger. Scott had previously agreed to remain incarcerated after waiving his detention hearing. Those decisions affect only pretrial custody. They do not establish that either defendant committed the crimes charged, and the defense will have opportunities to challenge the prosecution’s witnesses, forensic evidence and interpretation of events.

The New Jersey Department of Children and Families has separately investigated allegations involving Maya, while her younger sibling was taken into emergency care. That inquiry has added another unanswered layer to the case: what authorities or relatives knew before Oct. 13 and whether any earlier information could have changed Maya’s circumstances. Public reporting has included statements from family members describing concerns about alleged abuse, but a complete official accounting of agency contacts and decisions has not been released.

For residents, those unresolved institutional questions came after a more immediate response: mourning a child. The vigil and memorials placed the focus on Maya rather than on the defendants whose names dominated the first days of news coverage. In a case filled with allegations about what happened inside a private home, the community’s public remembrance also reflected how little many people understood about the child’s life before police and emergency workers arrived that October morning.

More than a month after Maya’s death, the central criminal allegations remained pending. Prosecutors say the hit-and-run account collapsed because the physical evidence, medical findings and surveillance record pointed elsewhere. Miller’s defense has already signaled that domestic violence allegations involving Scott will be part of its response. The child-welfare investigation and policy debate over homeschooling have continued on separate tracks, while both defendants remained in custody awaiting further proceedings.

The case that first sent officers searching Paulsboro streets for a fleeing motorist now centers on evidence collected from a home, a hospital, family interviews and surveillance recordings. Its legal outcome remains undecided. For the community that gathered with candles and balloons, however, the undisputed loss at the center of those proceedings is Maya Thomas, who was 9 years old when she died.

Author note: Last updated November 21, 2026.