The prosecution’s account describes a hunting trip, mounting concern and an aborted effort to move Allan Christopherson’s body before police arrived.
CASEY TOWNSHIP, Wis. — The hours before deputies found longtime Wayzata teacher Allan Gregory Christopherson dead at his family’s Wisconsin cabin began with an ordinary morning hunting trip and ended with a welfare check, an arrest and a first-degree intentional homicide case against his 25-year-old son, according to a criminal complaint.
The complaint, as described by several news organizations, provides a chronology built from a hunting companion’s observations, what deputies saw at the property and statements investigators attribute to Colton Douglas Christopherson. Prosecutors allege Colton killed his 56-year-old father Sept. 26, moved his body to nearby hunting land and brought it back after encountering another person there. Colton Christopherson has been charged with first-degree intentional homicide. He has not been convicted, and the allegations remain subject to challenge in court.
Earlier that day, Allan Christopherson went hunting with a neighbor, according to reports on the charging document. The companion left before Allan did because the other man had an unrelated family matter to handle. Later, when the neighbor was unable to reach Allan, he returned to the hunting property to check on him. Instead, he encountered Colton Christopherson. FOX 9’s account of the complaint says Colton was acting strangely and made an unusual remark before leaving the area.
The neighbor’s concern grew when Colton later contacted him with a request involving the hunting property. According to the complaint, Colton asked the man to follow him in another vehicle while Colton drove Allan’s truck to the hunting land, apparently so the neighbor could then give him a ride back to the cabin. The neighbor refused because the request seemed odd. Those interactions occurred before law enforcement arrived and later became part of investigators’ effort to reconstruct what had happened to Allan.
At some point, a caller asked the Washburn County Sheriff’s Office to conduct a welfare check at the Christopherson property near McKenzie Lake. The caller reported tension between father and son and said Colton had been acting unusually, according to the complaint. The caller also raised concerns that Colton might be using drugs. Deputies were dispatched to the rural cabin, roughly 10 miles northwest of Spooner, not initially for a confirmed violent crime but to check Allan’s well-being.
As officers arrived, Colton Christopherson came from the attached garage or cabin area, prosecutors say. The complaint describes him as nervous. One account says he extended his hand toward a deputy as officers began speaking with him. When asked where his father was, he allegedly lowered his head, looked toward the house and said Allan was dead. A deputy asked how he had died. According to the complaint, Colton replied, “I killed him.” Deputies immediately placed him in handcuffs.
Prosecutors say Colton told the deputies his father had been dead for more than an hour and said a knife had been used. He allegedly directed officers toward the location of the body and a weapon. Deputies then entered the cabin. In the basement laundry area, they found Allan Christopherson face down and partly covered by a green tarp, according to court reporting. An officer checked him and determined he had no pulse. The scene was then treated as a homicide investigation.
The condition of the cabin added another layer to the chronology. Investigators reported blood on floors and walls, bloody footprints and areas that appeared to have been cleaned. Two orange-handled knives were recovered, according to accounts of the complaint. Officers also found a garbage bag in the garage containing clothing and shoes with blood on them. The charging document alleges those items and conditions were connected to events after Allan was attacked, though the state would have to prove the relevance and meaning of that evidence in court.
Investigators say Colton later gave a statement describing what happened before deputies reached the property. According to the complaint, he said he stabbed his father in the neck and did not call for emergency help or provide aid. He then allegedly placed Allan’s body in a vehicle and drove to the hunting land. His stated plan, prosecutors say, was to bury his father there. But someone else was present, and Colton allegedly decided he could not proceed without being seen.
That encounter helps explain why the body was back at the cabin when deputies arrived. Colton allegedly told investigators that he drove his father back to the residence and moved him inside. Prosecutors say he intended to wait until dark and then return to the hunting property. The earlier request that the neighbor follow him there and provide a ride back takes on added significance in the state’s timeline because it allegedly occurred while Colton was trying to manage transportation between the two locations.
The complaint also describes what investigators say led Colton to travel from Minnesota to Wisconsin in the first place. He allegedly said he believed his father had hired someone to kill him and that he had noticed passing vehicles whose colors and license plates appeared significant to him. Prosecutors say he went to confront Allan about that belief and later claimed his father admitted arranging such a plan. No independent evidence confirming that allegation against Allan has been identified in the reporting reviewed for this article. It remains a belief and statement attributed to Colton, not an established fact.
After the arrest, the case moved from the wooded property into Washburn County Circuit Court. Colton Christopherson was charged with first-degree intentional homicide and later appeared before a judge. Reporting in October said the court set bail at $5 million. The judge also ordered a competency examination, and a hearing was scheduled for Dec. 7. That proceeding is intended to address whether Colton is currently able to understand the case and assist in his defense, rather than whether prosecutors can prove the homicide charge.
The investigation also brought wider attention to who Allan Christopherson was outside the cabin. He had worked for Wayzata Public Schools in Minnesota since the 1998-99 school year, teaching mathematics and serving in several coaching roles. School officials said he had strong relationships with students and colleagues. His athletic career included years coaching basketball and a decade leading the boys golf program, where Wayzata won state championships in 2010, 2011, 2015 and 2017.
In 2026, Christopherson remained involved in school athletics as a developmental coach for the girls golf program. After his death, the Wayzata golf community described him as one of the program’s most important coaches and said he had influenced hundreds of young players. Principal Scott Gengler told families that Christopherson was widely viewed as a caring and highly effective educator. His obituary also records community and church service beyond his work at the high school.
Those tributes followed the criminal investigation rather than explaining it. Authorities have not established in the reports reviewed that Allan had taken any action that would support the alleged threat described by his son. The state’s case instead rests on the sequence outlined in the complaint: the morning hunting trip, concern from people trying to locate Allan, interactions involving Colton, the welfare check, physical evidence at the cabin and statements prosecutors say Colton made before and after his arrest.
That chronology will remain an allegation unless proved through the criminal process. Colton Christopherson remains charged with first-degree intentional homicide, and his competency hearing is scheduled for Dec. 7. The court’s next decisions will determine how the case proceeds, while the central factual and legal questions surrounding Allan Christopherson’s death remain unresolved before a judge or jury.
Author note: Last updated November 20, 2026.