Recorded call captures Virginia father admitting he shook crying 5-month-old baby boy

Skottie’s relatives watched prosecutors reconstruct his final days through medical testimony, police accounts and a phone call recorded from the hospital.

HOPEWELL, Va. — Sarina Aldrich entered a Hopewell courtroom in October knowing prosecutors would revisit the five days that ended with her infant son’s death. What she and other relatives heard included medical testimony, police accounts and a recorded call in which the child’s father acknowledged shaking him.

The hearing placed the family’s experience at the center of a criminal case that had been developing since June. Aldrich’s son, identified by relatives as Skottie, was 5 months old when emergency crews found him unresponsive at a motel on Oaklawn Boulevard. His father, Nathan Travis-Nunnally, 22, was arrested while the child was still hospitalized and later charged with felony homicide after Skottie died. On Oct. 15, Judge Robert J. Fierro Jr. heard enough evidence to certify that charge, along with child abuse and aggravated malicious wounding, to a grand jury.

Aldrich was not present when the medical emergency began. She testified that she had reported to Riverside Regional Jail to serve a weekend sentence, leaving Travis-Nunnally with the baby. She said she and Travis-Nunnally had once been engaged but had recently broken up and that she planned to leave him. Her testimony did not describe the physical events inside the motel room because she did not witness them. Instead, it established why the child’s father was caring for him and why other evidence would be needed to reconstruct what happened.

One of the people who helped create that evidence was Skottie’s uncle. While the baby was being treated in intensive care, the uncle called Travis-Nunnally and recorded the conversation, according to testimony reported by WTVR. Prosecutors later played the recording in court. In it, Travis-Nunnally said he wanted the baby to be quiet, admitted yelling and said he picked the child up and shook him. The uncle’s questions and Travis-Nunnally’s responses turned a private hospital-period conversation into evidence that prosecutors relied on months later.

The recording was heard against a medical account of an infant who had already suffered a severe crisis before he reached the intensive care unit. Dr. Robin Foster of Children’s Hospital of Richmond at VCU testified that Skottie had been in cardiac arrest for an extended period and suffered major brain injury. Police had earlier said his injuries were consistent with shaken baby syndrome. The infant was treated at more than one hospital after the June 14 emergency call before he was admitted to the children’s hospital, where his family remained as doctors cared for him.

Skottie died June 19. Hopewell police announced the death in an update three days later and added felony homicide to the child abuse and aggravated malicious wounding charges already pending against Travis-Nunnally. The department’s release gave a precise beginning to the case: dispatchers received the call at 10:41 a.m. June 14, officers and firefighters responded to the 4900 block of Oaklawn Boulevard, and emergency medical personnel immediately began life-support measures. The official statement did not provide the later courtroom details about the recorded call or the family’s testimony.

Those details emerged slowly. Officer C. Foley testified that Travis-Nunnally told him the baby had become excessively fussy and then suddenly went limp. A detective said Travis-Nunnally reported trying to settle his son after feeding him. Earlier court-document reporting said Travis-Nunnally described being unable to tolerate the baby’s continued crying. Prosecutors used the recorded conversation to add Travis-Nunnally’s later acknowledgment that he shook the child. The defense remains entitled to challenge how those statements should be understood and whether the state can prove every element of the charges.

The family also heard the defense question a circumstance from Skottie’s ordinary medical care before June 14. The baby wore a cranial helmet intended to correct the shape of his skull. Defense questioning explored whether the helmet could have affected the injuries doctors observed. Foster testified that Skottie had been healthy and was nearing the end of his helmet treatment. The exchange did not settle the case’s medical issues, but it showed that the defense was examining whether factors other than the prosecution’s account could bear on the severity of the child’s condition.

Outside the courthouse, Aldrich described Skottie in terms that had little to do with medical findings or criminal charges. She said he had been her heart and soul and described the difficulty of hearing the evidence all at once. WTVR reported that she carried one of his favorite toys, a Tigger, while talking about a baby who enjoyed children’s television programs and familiar characters. Those details offered a view of Skottie beyond the courtroom language that now surrounds his death, while the legal proceeding itself remained focused on evidence and the charges against his father.

Skottie’s grandparents were also among the relatives at the hearing. His grandfather Shane Aldrich described Skottie as his first grandson and said he wanted justice. Such statements reflect the family’s loss but do not decide the criminal case. The responsibility for determining whether the prosecution can prove its allegations remains with the courts. Fierro’s preliminary-hearing ruling allowed the case to move forward without making a finding that Travis-Nunnally committed the charged offenses.

Another part of Travis-Nunnally’s history surfaced through court records rather than family testimony. WTVR reported that he had been charged after a separate 2025 domestic incident in Petersburg. In that case, a judge found facts sufficient for conviction on an assault allegation but deferred the final outcome and ordered Travis-Nunnally to complete anger-management programming. Records showed the requirement was not completed by the deadline and that he missed an April 2026 hearing. The older matter is distinct from Skottie’s death and does not establish guilt in the current prosecution.

The family’s loss and the state’s case now move on different tracks. Skottie’s relatives have already lived through the emergency response, hospital treatment, his death and a preliminary hearing that replayed some of Travis-Nunnally’s words. Prosecutors, meanwhile, still must move through the remaining criminal process. Public reporting has not established a final plea, a trial date or a complete defense position. It also has not established that a grand jury has already acted. Those gaps are important because the criminal allegations remain unresolved.

The next expected proceeding is grand-jury review. WTVR reported that the panel was expected to consider the three certified charges in December after Fierro’s Oct. 15 ruling. As of Nov. 21, no later reliable public account reviewed for this article documented that step. The most recent confirmed court action therefore remains the certification of felony homicide, child abuse and aggravated malicious wounding charges against Travis-Nunnally, who is presumed innocent unless and until guilt is established through the judicial process.

Author note: Last updated November 21, 2026.