A Honda Passport’s recorded speed and steering movements gave jurors a technical path through competing explanations of Daniel Waterman’s fatal crash.
BUNNELL, Fla. — In the final seconds before a Honda Passport left Interstate 95 and entered the trees, its onboard systems recorded numbers and movements that would later become some of the most important evidence in a Florida vehicular-homicide trial.
Those data helped prosecutors convict Leigha Catherine Marie Mumby, 25, in the death of her boyfriend, Daniel Waterman. A Flagler County jury found Mumby guilty Oct. 14 of vehicular homicide and reckless driving causing serious bodily injury after hearing competing interpretations of the SUV’s speed, throttle use and steering. Jurors deliberated about 71 minutes. Circuit Judge Dawn Nichols revoked Mumby’s bond after the verdict, sending her into custody while she awaits a Dec. 2 sentencing hearing at which she faces up to 20 years in prison.
The case required jurors to reconstruct an event that unfolded in seconds but had consequences lasting months. Mumby was driving a white 2019 Honda Passport north on I-95 in Flagler County on Feb. 9, 2025, with Waterman in the passenger seat. The pair had left a Super Bowl gathering and were arguing. Prosecutors said Mumby had learned that morning that she was pregnant and was upset about Waterman communicating with another woman. What happened inside the SUV immediately before it left the highway remained contested. What the vehicle itself recorded was more concrete.
Investigators examining the Honda’s event data found it moving at roughly 93 to 95 mph several seconds before the collision, according to court reporting. Evidence described before trial showed a pronounced steering input, followed by another movement in the opposite direction as the SUV left the roadway. At one point in the sequence, trial reporting placed the vehicle at about 94 mph. Other investigative reporting said the Honda’s speed had fallen substantially by impact. The prosecution characterized the series as the product of dangerously aggressive driving; the defense treated the second movement as evidence that Mumby was trying to recover control.
That distinction was crucial. Prosecutors were not required on the vehicular-homicide count to prove that Mumby consciously decided to kill Waterman. They had to show that she operated the vehicle in a reckless manner likely to cause death or great bodily harm and that her conduct caused his death. Assistant State Attorney Melissa Clark argued that the speed alone was dangerous and that the sudden steering during an argument made the situation substantially worse. She told jurors that Mumby had been driving at extreme speeds and aggressively before the crash.
Defense attorney Reid Hart urged jurors not to treat a rapid sequence of vehicle inputs as proof of criminal recklessness without considering the possibility of an unexpected disturbance. The defense argued that something happened that Mumby neither anticipated nor controlled and said her response after the initial movement was consistent with trying to avoid the trees. Hart also pointed to the danger Mumby faced herself. She was in the driver’s seat and had learned that day she was pregnant, circumstances the defense argued made it unlikely she would intentionally create a potentially fatal crash.
Intent had once occupied a larger role in the case. Months before trial, Daniel Waterman told investigators that he believed Mumby intentionally caused the collision. He made the statement after awakening from a coma and while still severely impaired from his injuries. According to the criminal complaint, he said Mumby had been driving recklessly as the two argued and accused her of accelerating after he tried to leave the SUV. He also attributed to her the statement, “I don’t care what happens, you’ll get what you deserve,” shortly before the crash.
Jurors never heard that account. Nichols ruled before trial that Waterman’s statements could not be admitted under the applicable evidentiary rules. The prosecutor acknowledged at the hearing that she did not have a sufficient legal path to introduce them. Because Waterman had died by then, he could not testify in court or be cross-examined. Prosecutors subsequently dropped an aggravated-battery charge that more directly rested on an allegation that Mumby intentionally used the vehicle to harm him.
The exclusion made the technical evidence more important. Without Waterman telling jurors what he believed Mumby had done, the state needed the Honda, the crash scene and other witnesses to establish how the SUV was being operated. An accident reconstructionist described the steering behavior in court. Prosecutors used the data to argue that the vehicle was already traveling at an exceptionally dangerous speed before it veered toward the roadside. They also presented evidence about the dispute between Mumby and Waterman to place the driving in context, while avoiding reliance on his barred accusation.
The defense found ambiguity in the same data. A steering wheel can record an abrupt movement without explaining why the driver made it. A later correction can be characterized as an attempt to avoid impact or simply as part of a loss of control. Speed measurements can establish how fast a vehicle was traveling but not, standing alone, what a driver intended. Hart used those limitations to argue that prosecutors had not eliminated an accidental explanation. The jury’s verdict showed that it nevertheless concluded the manner of driving was sufficiently reckless for criminal liability.
The human consequences behind those measurements were severe. Waterman suffered a broken neck and paralysis from the neck down, according to the State Attorney’s Office. He spent months receiving medical treatment and at one stage emerged from a coma sufficiently to communicate with investigators. He died Oct. 8, 2025, after developing pneumonia. His death led prosecutors to add the vehicular-homicide charge later that month. He was 22.
Waterman’s death also complicated the prosecution in another way. His interview had helped investigators develop their understanding of the crash, but his absence meant the defense could not question him in court. That contributed to the pretrial battle over hearsay and confrontation rights and ultimately narrowed what jurors could hear. As a result, the state’s trial was different from the earlier criminal complaint that had made Waterman’s accusation central. By October 2026, the legal case depended much more heavily on proving dangerous conduct through reconstruction than on proving a deliberate act through his words.
After the verdict, State Attorney R.J. Larizza emphasized the technical character of the prosecution. He said the case demonstrated his office’s commitment to handling matters involving complicated subject material. The Florida Highway Patrol investigated the crash, and Clark prosecuted the case. Mumby cried as the verdict was read, according to courtroom reports, before Nichols ordered her remanded to jail.
The verdict does not mean every factual question about the last seconds inside the Honda was answered. Mumby had told investigators she could not remember what caused the crash. Waterman’s account was never tested before the trial jury. The defense maintained that something unexpected could have produced the steering movement, while prosecutors argued that the combination of speed, anger and driving behavior amounted to a conscious disregard of safety. Criminal jurors were not required to settle every unknown; they were required to decide whether the evidence proved the charged offenses beyond a reasonable doubt, and they concluded that it did.
The case now moves from reconstruction to punishment. FlaglerLive reported that Nichols has scheduled Mumby’s sentencing for Dec. 2. She remains in custody following the revocation of her bond and faces as much as 20 years on the two convictions. At sentencing, the central question will no longer be what the Honda’s data prove about the crash. It will be how the court should punish conduct that jurors have already found criminally reckless and responsible for Waterman’s death.
Author note: Last updated Nov. 20, 2026.