Police say Orlando doctor delayed rescue after friend’s 7-year-old son vanished underwater

Investigators say recorded footage showed a much longer emergency than Sukanthini Subbiah initially described after 7-year-old Khushil Bandi was pulled from the water.

ORLANDO, Fla. — Sukanthini “Suki” Subbiah told investigators that the 7-year-old boy she had taken swimming was underwater for a relatively brief period before she sought help. Orlando police say a surveillance camera showed something substantially different — a discrepancy now at the heart of an aggravated manslaughter case.

Khushil Bandi died after the April 10 outing, and Subbiah, a 48-year-old Louisiana physician, has pleaded not guilty to aggravated manslaughter of a child. Police say the recording shows Khushil struggling, disappearing beneath the surface and remaining there for several minutes while Subbiah was in a position to respond. Subbiah told investigators she froze during the emergency. Her attorney says the death was an accident and that prosecutors should not treat her response as a crime. The case now depends in significant part on how investigators, lawyers and eventually the court evaluate the difference between human recollection and the recorded sequence.

Subbiah’s initial statement described an outing that had appeared routine until she noticed Khushil underwater. She had been visiting her mother in Orlando with her own 7-year-old son. Her son had made friends with Khushil and his twin sister, who lived nearby, and police said the twins’ mother permitted Subbiah to take them to the community swimming pool. The girl wore a life vest. Khushil did not, and Subbiah told detectives she assumed from that fact that he could swim.

After the drowning, Subbiah told detectives she believed she had seen Khushil submerged for about 45 seconds before responding, according to the police account. She said the other two children tried unsuccessfully to get him and that another adult ultimately pulled him from the water. She then performed CPR and called 911. She also explained why her mother, though present, did not conduct the rescue: her mother could not swim. Standing alone, that description suggested an emergency that developed and prompted action within a relatively short period.

The camera footage supplied investigators with a clock. Police say the children entered the pool at about 6:19 p.m. Within roughly a minute, Khushil’s behavior changed. Detectives described him turning and splashing vigorously as he struggled in the water. After more than a minute of distress, he went beneath the surface around 6:21 p.m. The recording therefore established a starting point investigators could compare with the movements of everyone else visible near the pool.

Other details took on new importance when viewed in that sequence. Police said Subbiah moved near the edge of the pool and at one point appeared to make a shushing gesture. Her son asked her to retrieve his goggles, and she did so while the situation involving Khushil was unfolding. Detectives also said the footage showed her looking toward the center of the pool after Khushil had submerged. Those observations do not themselves establish what she understood at each instant, but investigators interpreted them as evidence that she had opportunities to recognize the emergency before she acted.

The young witnesses added another layer. By about 6:23 p.m., according to police, the children began asking what had happened to Khushil. Their later statements reflected their age and uncertainty about what they had seen. One child apparently interpreted the boy’s stillness as sleep, while another described him as being at the bottom of the pool. Investigators did not treat those childhood descriptions as a precise measure of time. Instead, they compared them with the video, which documented when Khushil disappeared beneath the water and when the adults responded.

Police say Subbiah finally stepped into the pool around 6:26 p.m., roughly five minutes after Khushil went under. Investigators allege she stopped when the water reached about her knees rather than moving directly to him. She then asked the other 7-year-olds to try to retrieve Khushil, according to the arrest account. They could not. The decision to turn to children for the first attempted recovery became an important part of investigators’ argument that her conduct went beyond a momentary failure to understand what was happening.

Another man at the pool was then asked to intervene. He entered the water and brought Khushil up. Police calculated that more than seven minutes had elapsed between the boy’s submersion and his removal from the pool. Subbiah began resuscitation efforts once Khushil was out of the water. He was taken for emergency medical treatment but later died. The prosecution theory is therefore not that Subbiah took no action at all. It is that the meaningful rescue came far too late despite what investigators describe as repeated chances for her to act sooner.

When detectives interviewed Subbiah again, her estimate changed. She said Khushil may have been underwater for about two minutes and acknowledged that such a duration would be unrealistic for a 7-year-old to simply hold his breath, according to investigators. She said she froze. That explanation could become a major point of dispute because it addresses her state of mind rather than the stopwatch chronology. A person can panic during an emergency even when later video makes the appropriate response appear obvious. Police, however, say her professional training and responsibility for the child made the delay especially serious.

Investigators cited Subbiah’s work as a physician in arguing that she knew the medical risk of prolonged submersion. In their view, her training meant she should have understood that every additional minute without breathing increased the danger. The defense views her profession differently. Attorney Rajan Joshi has described Subbiah as someone who built a career around caring for people and has said the case should not turn a tragic accident into a criminal prosecution. He also said she cooperated with police and voluntarily surrendered after the charge was filed.

The competing accounts illustrate the different roles of evidence in a criminal investigation. A statement can establish what a witness or suspect remembers or claims to remember. Video can establish visible actions and elapsed time. Neither automatically answers every legal question. The camera cannot show precisely what Subbiah perceived, while memory cannot override a reliable recording of when events occurred. Prosecutors must connect those forms of evidence to Florida’s requirement that aggravated manslaughter of a child involve a death caused through culpable negligence.

That burden is higher than showing that Subbiah made mistakes. The state must prove the charged offense in court, where the defense can challenge the interpretation of the footage, question witnesses and dispute whether her conduct caused Khushil’s death in the manner alleged. Police have said the boy could have been removed substantially earlier had Subbiah responded when his prolonged submersion became apparent. That is an investigative conclusion, not yet a judicial finding, and Subbiah retains the presumption of innocence.

The discrepancy nevertheless explains why a case first regarded as an accidental drowning ultimately produced an arrest months later. Investigators had a detailed recording against which they could test the initial descriptions of the incident. Their conclusion was that the gap between those accounts and the video was not minor: it changed the perceived duration of the emergency from seconds to minutes and placed Subbiah near the scene throughout the period they considered critical.

Subbiah remains charged and has entered a not-guilty plea. Her attorney has said she intends to fight the allegation, while the state’s public case rests heavily on the surveillance timeline and investigators’ interpretation of her responsibility for Khushil. A review of available reporting through Nov. 17 did not establish a later verdict or other final resolution. Until a court determines the case, the differences between what Subbiah recalled, what the camera recorded and what the law requires remain unresolved.

Author note: Last updated November 17, 2026.