Prosecutors traced Michael Freund’s murder case through a crucial sequence: an argument, a trip for a handgun, a return and the fatal shooting of Dexter Perkins.
WHEATON, Ill. — At a key point in an escalating argument at a suburban Chicago bar, Michael Freund walked away from the dispute, went to his pickup truck, retrieved a handgun and returned.
That sequence became central to the prosecution of Freund, who was convicted Oct. 9 of first-degree murder in the 2023 killing of Dexter Perkins outside Rosie O’Reilly’s in unincorporated Wheaton. The men had been strangers when they crossed paths earlier that morning. Their disagreement involved pizza and a bar tab, but prosecutors presented the homicide as the result of a series of choices made after the dispute began. Freund’s attorney argued that the final shooting was an act of self-defense. Jurors rejected that defense after a three-day trial.
The case began with no reported connection between Freund and Perkins. Freund and two co-workers arrived at the bar about 7:20 a.m. Dec. 22, 2023, after finishing work. Perkins, 37, was already there. The men began talking and socializing. Trial reporting described surveillance video showing them together at the bar, and prosecutors said Perkins bought a round of shots. The group also shared food. At that stage, nothing in the available public record suggested the encounter was headed toward deadly violence.
A second pizza became the source of the argument that followed. Prosecutors said Perkins gave Freund and one co-worker a slice each, then kept most of what remained. Published accounts said Perkins planned to take the leftovers with him. The men began arguing about the pizza and the bill. Evidence described during the trial indicated the bartender offered to remove the pizza from Freund’s tab, but the conflict continued.
Freund then left for his truck. Prosecutors said he retrieved a 9 mm Glock and brought it back into the situation. Trial coverage said prosecutors also presented evidence that Freund offered another handgun to one of his co-workers, who declined it. That trip became one of the most significant points in the prosecution’s timeline because it happened after the initial disagreement began but before Perkins was fatally shot.
The state’s theory required jurors to look at the sequence as a whole. Prosecutors did not argue merely that Freund fired a gun and Perkins died. They sought to establish why Freund’s claim of self-defense should be rejected by showing the decisions made before the final confrontation. The trip to the truck gave the state a way to argue that Freund had separated himself from the dispute, obtained a deadly weapon and then returned rather than being suddenly forced to react without opportunity for any other course of action.
The defense approached the chronology differently. Attorney Dave Carlson focused on what occurred after the men moved onto the bar’s deck or porch. Perkins and one of Freund’s co-workers became physically involved. Prosecutors described a brief scuffle and pointed to cellphone video that reportedly showed the pair in close contact, including moments the state characterized as a bear hug or dancing. Carlson disputed that description and argued that the confrontation was much more serious.
That disagreement about the video was more than a dispute over wording. It went directly to Freund’s self-defense theory. If jurors believed the situation presented an immediate threat of serious harm, that would affect their assessment of Freund’s decision to use force. If they accepted the prosecution’s description of the encounter and its broader chronology, the same gunfire could be viewed as unjustified. The trial therefore turned in substantial part on how jurors interpreted both the recorded evidence and the actions preceding it.
Prosecutors said Freund drew the Glock and fired two shots into the air. The physical confrontation continued. Trial reporting indicated that Perkins went to the ground and later stood again. When he advanced toward the other man, Freund opened fire from the other side of a wooden railing, according to the state. Perkins was struck multiple times and died at the scene. Prosecutors emphasized that he was unarmed.
What happened next was more straightforward. Authorities said Freund took the handgun back to his pickup and placed it in the center console. At about 8:40 a.m., DuPage County sheriff’s deputies were dispatched to Rosie O’Reilly’s following a report of shots fired. They found Perkins dead. Freund was still at the business and was taken into custody without incident. Investigators later recovered the handgun from the truck.
Freund was charged with first-degree murder. At his initial court appearance, a judge granted prosecutors’ request to keep him in custody while the case proceeded. The allegation then remained unresolved for nearly three years. During that period, Freund was an accused defendant and retained the presumption of innocence. The state still had to establish its case at trial, including overcoming the defense position that the shooting was justified.
When the trial began in October 2026, Assistant State’s Attorney Lee Roupas argued that Freund’s conduct had no legal justification. Prosecutors used the chronology to challenge any suggestion that the shooting could be judged solely by a few seconds of physical contact outside. Carlson, meanwhile, described the death as tragic but contested the state’s murder theory and argued that Freund was responding to what he believed was a dangerous confrontation.
The prosecution’s presentation also helped distinguish motive from legal responsibility. The dispute over pizza and the tab explained how the tension began, but prosecutors still needed evidence supporting every element of first-degree murder. The jury was not asked to convict Freund merely because the argument seemed trivial or because the outcome was severe. Jurors had to decide whether prosecutors had proved the charged crime beyond a reasonable doubt and whether the defense explanation created legal justification for the shooting.
After three days of testimony and evidence, jurors deliberated for less than an hour. They found Freund guilty of first-degree murder. The verdict represented a rejection of the self-defense argument and accepted the prosecution’s case that Freund’s use of deadly force was unlawful. It also moved the case beyond the allegation stage that had existed since his December 2023 arrest.
DuPage County State’s Attorney Bob Berlin said after the verdict that Perkins’ death had left a lasting impact on his loved ones. Perkins was the father of two daughters. Berlin said the conviction could not restore Perkins to his family but expressed hope that the result would bring some measure of accountability. The case had remained unresolved for nearly three years by the time jurors returned the verdict.
The shorthand description of the killing as a shooting “over pizza” remains attention-grabbing, but the prosecution’s timeline showed why the case involved more than a single argument about food. The initial dispute was followed by Freund’s trip to the truck, his return with a firearm, movement onto the porch, a separate physical confrontation, warning shots and finally the gunfire that killed Perkins. The jury’s task was to evaluate those stages together.
The chronology also explains why the truck became more than a location in the case. It was where prosecutors said Freund obtained the gun before the shooting and where he later returned it. In the state’s presentation, the vehicle connected events before and after Perkins was killed and helped establish that the firearm was not simply introduced at the instant of the final confrontation.
From the argument inside the bar to Freund’s trip to his truck and the shooting outside, prosecutors ultimately persuaded jurors that the sequence amounted to murder rather than lawful self-defense. The next phase was expected to address post-trial motions and sentencing, beginning with a Nov. 9 court date. The material reviewed here does not verify the result of that proceeding, so no later sentence can be stated as confirmed.
Author note: Last updated Nov. 20, 2026.