Pennsylvania park argument explodes into gunfire as 16-year-old boy shoots another teen in the face then runs

Jay-Quan Edward Williams was 16 when police arrested him after a park-area shooting and 17 when he pleaded guilty in county court.

LANCASTER, Pa. — Jay-Quan Edward Williams entered the criminal justice system as a 16-year-old charged as an adult and emerged from the case at 17 with a sentence of 9 1/2 to 20 years in state prison for shooting another juvenile during a Lancaster confrontation.

The shift from juvenile defendant by age to adult prosecution by law shaped the case from its earliest days. Lancaster City police arrested Williams on Oct. 10, 2025, two days after a shooting near Culliton Park, and announced that he would face adult criminal charges. Those charges included attempted criminal homicide, two counts of aggravated assault, reckless endangerment and three firearm offenses. Nearly a year later, Williams pleaded guilty to each of the offenses identified by the district attorney’s office and was sentenced by Lancaster County Judge Thomas Sponaugle.

Williams’ age remained an unavoidable part of the proceeding even though the case was handled in adult court. He was 16 when authorities said he carried a concealed handgun to the area near the park, confronted another juvenile and fired a single round into the teenager’s face. He was 17 by the time he stood before Sponaugle for sentencing. The victim was also a juvenile, meaning the event put two young people at the center of an adult criminal prosecution with consequences extending well beyond their teenage years.

The shooting occurred during the afternoon of Oct. 8, 2025, in the 200 block of West Strawberry Street near Culliton Park. Police were dispatched after a report of gunfire and found a wounded person who was taken to a medical facility. Later statements from prosecutors said the bullet struck the victim in the face, severely damaged the jaw and required surgical treatment. The victim survived, and authorities have continued to withhold the juvenile’s identity from the public reports reviewed for this article.

Police and prosecutors said surveillance video helped establish what occurred before the shot. The footage showed Williams among a group of juveniles, including the victim. The interaction became heated, authorities said, and Williams questioned whether the victim wanted to die before producing a handgun hidden in his waistband. The victim then walked away and began speaking with another person. Williams fired once and fled, according to the district attorney’s office.

After Williams was arrested, prosecutors pursued an attempted criminal homicide count along with two aggravated assault charges. They also charged him with recklessly endangering another person, possession of a firearm by a minor, carrying a firearm without a license and possession of a firearm by a person prohibited from doing so. The combination meant the prosecution addressed not only the act of firing at the victim but also Williams’ possession and concealed carrying of the handgun.

One firearm charge followed directly from Williams’ age. The district attorney’s office noted that a juvenile was not eligible to carry the concealed weapon described in the case. Another charge alleged that Williams was legally prohibited from firearm possession. The publicly available prosecution summaries do not explain the specific basis for that prohibition, so the record reviewed for this report does not support a more detailed account of why that count applied.

The next major court step came on Nov. 6, 2025, when Williams waived his preliminary hearing before Judge Adam Witkonis. The decision allowed the charges to proceed to Lancaster County Court without prosecutors presenting their evidence at a preliminary hearing. At that time, the district attorney’s office said Williams remained in the Lancaster County Youth Intervention Center in lieu of $250,000 bail. He had not yet been convicted, and the charges remained allegations until his later guilty pleas.

The contrast between his detention setting and his adult prosecution reflected his status at the time: Williams was still legally a minor in age while facing a serious adult criminal case. The prosecution continued for months after the preliminary stage. No public account reviewed for this article indicates that the case went to trial or that a jury was selected. Instead, the matter was resolved when Williams appeared in court on Sept. 24, 2026, and admitted the offenses.

Those guilty pleas fundamentally changed his legal status. Williams admitted attempted criminal homicide, two aggravated assault counts, reckless endangerment, firearm possession as a minor, carrying a firearm without a license and prohibited firearm possession. Because he pleaded guilty, prosecutors did not have to prove the charges to a jury beyond a reasonable doubt. The court could instead move to sentencing based on the convictions created by the pleas.

Sponaugle imposed a minimum prison term of 9 1/2 years and a maximum of 20 years. The judge also required Williams to pay more than $13,000 in restitution for the victim’s medical expenses. The restitution tied the sentence to the physical consequences of the shooting, which prosecutors said required surgery. Officials have not released a broader accounting of the victim’s recovery, future treatment needs or other personal effects of the injury.

The sentencing hearing brought competing consequences into the same courtroom. Sponaugle described the case as profoundly sad and focused on how quickly Williams had made a decision carrying years of consequences. Williams declined an opportunity to address the judge directly. His attorney said the shooting had permanently changed the lives of two young men and told the court Williams was remorseful and accepting responsibility.

For the victim, the public record centers on injury, surgery and medical bills rather than a detailed biography. For Williams, the record is much more extensive because he became the named defendant in an adult criminal proceeding. That difference is consistent with the way authorities handled the case: the injured juvenile remained unidentified, while Williams’ name, charges, detention status, plea and sentence became part of public court reporting.

The adult prosecution also meant that Williams faced a sentencing framework far removed from the short-term intervention associated with many juvenile cases. His sentence runs as long as 20 years in state prison. The reports reviewed for this article do not state a precise future release date, and the minimum-to-maximum structure should not be read as a guarantee that Williams will leave custody at the first possible point. The confirmed court action is the sentence Sponaugle imposed.

The case nevertheless began with the same facts that confronted officers on an October afternoon: two juveniles, a public area near a city park and one person seriously wounded by gunfire. What followed was an arrest within two days, adult charges against a 16-year-old, months of pretrial proceedings, guilty pleas at 17 and a sentence that may extend well into Williams’ adulthood.

For Williams, the case now extends far beyond the teenage years in which it began. He was 16 when the shooting occurred and 17 when he was sentenced, yet the maximum 20-year prison term reaches well into adulthood. The court’s ruling thus closes a prosecution defined from the outset by the decision to handle the juvenile defendant in the adult criminal system.

Author note: Last updated November 16, 2026.