Oklahoma City man admits killing nurse with 2×4 at car wash after escalating street feud

Billy Buford entered his plea without a negotiated punishment after originally facing a first-degree murder charge in Douglas Smitherman’s death.

OKLAHOMA CITY, Okla. — Billy Buford entered court knowing he would plead guilty to first-degree manslaughter but without knowing exactly what punishment the judge would impose. That decision ultimately produced a life sentence, with all but the first 16 years suspended, in the killing of Douglas Smitherman.

The sentencing is notable not only for its length but for the legal path that preceded it. Buford, 60, was initially prosecuted on a first-degree murder charge after investigators linked him to Smitherman’s May 2025 death at an Oklahoma City car wash. The case did not reach a murder trial. Instead, Buford pleaded guilty in May 2026 to the lesser offense of first-degree manslaughter. The plea was entered without an agreed sentence, leaving the judge to decide punishment after a presentencing investigation. Prosecutors announced in October that the court imposed life imprisonment while suspending the portion of the sentence beyond the first 16 years.

That sequence distinguishes Buford’s case from a plea agreement in which the prosecution and defense settle both the charge and a specified punishment before a defendant appears for sentencing. Here, the public reporting shows that the conviction was resolved but the punishment remained open. The court therefore retained discretion over the sentence after receiving additional information. The complete presentencing report has not been made public in the source material reviewed for this story, and neither the full prosecution argument nor the full defense presentation at sentencing is available. Any attempt to assign a specific reason to the judge’s choice of 16 unsuspended years would therefore require speculation.

The criminal case began with a much less settled picture. At 12:36 p.m. May 2, 2025, Oklahoma City police were called to a car wash at 2012 NW 122nd St. after a deceased person was reported. Officers identified the man as Douglas Eugene Smitherman, 48. Police said his injuries were consistent with homicide and listed his death as the city’s 24th homicide investigation of the year. The initial bulletin said no suspects were in custody. Investigators were still seeking information from the public nearly two weeks after the death and said little about what evidence might identify the person responsible.

Later investigative work shifted the focus to Buford. Authorities concluded that he repeatedly struck Smitherman in the head with a wooden 2-by-4 at the car wash. Prosecutors then brought the more serious murder accusation against him. Reports on the case say Buford was held on a high bond as the prosecution moved forward and was bound over for further court proceedings. Those developments reflected prosecutors’ theory of the case at that stage, but the murder accusation was never resolved by a jury verdict. Buford’s later guilty plea established his criminal liability on first-degree manslaughter instead.

The difference matters when describing the case accurately. It would be wrong to say Buford was convicted of first-degree murder simply because that was the original charge. His conviction is for first-degree manslaughter, the offense to which he admitted guilt. At the same time, the lesser conviction does not erase the investigative findings about the fatal assault. Authorities said Smitherman was repeatedly beaten with the board and died from the attack. Because Buford pleaded guilty, prosecutors did not have to present all of their evidence in a trial, and the public record consequently contains less courtroom testimony than might have emerged through a contested murder case.

Investigators also learned that the two men had a history of conflict shortly before Smitherman’s death. Authorities said they had fought and thrown bricks at each other in the days before the fatal encounter. That information helps establish that the killing was not necessarily the first confrontation between them, but it does not supply a complete motive. Officials have not publicly said what started the earlier dispute or what immediately led to the final assault at the car wash. A guilty plea answers who accepted responsibility for the criminal act; it does not automatically answer every factual question surrounding why it happened.

The structure of the sentence requires similar precision. Prosecutors described Buford as receiving life in prison with all but the first 16 years suspended. That formulation is different from saying the life sentence itself was suspended for 16 years, and it is also different from describing the judgment simply as a 16-year sentence. The first 16 years were the unsuspended portion, according to the sentencing announcement. Public reports reviewed for this story do not establish a reliable projected release date or set out all correctional rules that could affect the eventual duration of custody, so no additional calculation should be attached to the announced sentence.

The legal emphasis of the case can also obscure who Smitherman was before his name became part of a homicide prosecution. His mother, Barbara Smitherman, described him as a gifted and stylish man whom friends and relatives called “DougE Fresh.” She said he was a registered nurse who had worked as a house supervisor at McAlester Regional for about three years. His obituary said he graduated from McAlester High School in 1995 with a 4.0 grade-point average, later became a certified personal trainer and then completed a nursing degree at Eastern Oklahoma State College in the top third of his class.

Smitherman went on to work in hospitals around Oklahoma, including as a traveling nurse, according to the obituary. His family said he was known for caring about his patients. By 2025, he had returned to Oklahoma City because he wanted to rebuild his life away from the familiarity of McAlester. His mother said he believed too many people knew him there and hoped a move could give him another beginning. Instead, police found him dead at the car wash on May 2. The killing came several months after the death of his father, adding another loss for a family that would then spend the next year watching the prosecution develop.

The plea removed several uncertainties that would otherwise have been decided at trial. A jury did not have to determine whether Buford was responsible for Smitherman’s death because Buford admitted guilt to manslaughter. Witnesses did not have to publicly present the entire case against him, and prosecutors did not have to seek a murder verdict. But the blind nature of the plea introduced a different uncertainty for Buford: he did not secure a predetermined sentence as part of the resolution. The judge’s later decision to impose life with a substantial suspended portion became the final major judicial act described in the released accounts.

For prosecutors, the sentencing established punishment after a case that began with a murder allegation. For Smitherman’s relatives, it marked the end of the principal criminal proceeding but could not supply answers that authorities never publicly established, particularly the precise motive for the final encounter. The public record supports a history of conflict, the fatal beating, Buford’s prosecution and his eventual guilty plea. It does not support a more detailed explanation of his state of mind or a definitive account of why the violence escalated when it did.

Buford has now been convicted of first-degree manslaughter and sentenced, ending the need for a trial on the original murder charge. The announced judgment leaves the first 16 years of his life sentence unsuspended and the remainder suspended. Smitherman’s death, meanwhile, remains part of the record not only as a resolved criminal case but as the loss of a nurse and father who had moved to Oklahoma City hoping to begin again.

Author note: Last updated Nov. 21, 2026.