Ohio daycare operator killed premature twin after complaining about fussy babies

The prosecution of Tammra Straughter unfolded over three years after Kashan Crawford-Chatman stopped breathing while at her Reynoldsburg home.

COLUMBUS, Ohio — A call reporting a baby who had stopped breathing at a suburban Ohio home in October 2023 eventually became a homicide investigation, a murder indictment, a jury trial and, three years later, a life sentence for the woman who had been caring for him.

The final step in that trial-court sequence came Oct. 7, 2026, when Franklin County Common Pleas Judge Bill Sperlazza sentenced Tammra R. Straughter, 54, to life in prison for the death of 5-month-old Kashan Roman Crawford-Chatman. Straughter will be eligible for parole after serving at least 15 years and received credit for 54 days already served. Her sentence followed an Aug. 20 jury verdict finding her guilty of murder and child endangerment. The verdict ended a prosecution that depended on reconstructing what happened during several critical hours on Oct. 9, 2023.

That morning, Kashan and his twin brother were taken to Straughter’s Reynoldsburg home, where she operated an in-home child care service. The twins had been born prematurely in April and had spent several weeks in neonatal intensive care, according to a wrongful-death lawsuit filed by their mother, Stacia Crawford. By October, Crawford had returned to work. Prosecutors later said Straughter was alone that day with Kashan, his twin and six other children. Nothing publicly reported suggests Kashan was in medical distress when he arrived.

During the afternoon, the situation changed. Emergency responders were dispatched to Straughter’s home on a report that a young baby was not breathing. According to an affidavit cited by local media, Kashan had resumed breathing by the time responders arrived and appeared stable during their assessment. Police notified Crawford, and the baby was released to her. But the apparent improvement did not last. Crawford took her son to an urgent care center, where he again became critically ill.

Kashan was placed in an ambulance for transfer to Nationwide Children’s Hospital, but the trip was interrupted when his condition became so serious that the ambulance diverted to Mount Carmel East for stabilization. Court records described him going into cardiac arrest and requiring prolonged resuscitation. He was later transferred to Nationwide Children’s, where doctors identified severe injuries that changed the nature of the case. What had initially been presented as a breathing or choking emergency was now being treated as a suspected physical-abuse case.

Hospital personnel notified authorities after finding evidence of serious head trauma and other injuries. The Franklin County Coroner’s Office later determined that Kashan had died from a closed head injury consistent with shaken baby syndrome and classified his death as a homicide. Kashan died Oct. 13, 2023, four days after the emergency call. The date is confirmed by his obituary and by reporting from the 2024 court proceedings. A later secondary report referred to the killing as occurring in 2024, but the underlying event, hospitalization and death occurred in October 2023.

Straughter’s statements gave investigators one version of the crucial afternoon. She said the infant had been smiling and healthy when he and his brother arrived but became fussy as the day went on. According to an affidavit, she said she held him frequently, later placed him on his back to tend to another child and returned to find that he had spit up and appeared to be having trouble breathing. She said she used a nasal aspirator, patted his back, gave rescue breaths and called 911. In Crawford’s civil lawsuit, Straughter was also described as saying she struck Kashan on the back after he appeared to choke on formula.

Investigators worked to test that account against other evidence. Video discovered inside the home reportedly showed Kashan appearing well earlier in the day and established parts of the timeline before his condition deteriorated. A prosecutor said during the 2024 arraignment that Straughter had initially told authorities there was no camera recording in the home. The available reporting indicates that the footage did not show the act prosecutors ultimately said killed Kashan. Instead, it helped document his condition and movements during a day for which there were no independent adult witnesses described in the reports.

The inquiry also extended to Straughter’s phone. A detective who examined it with her permission found deleted text messages indicating that she had been frustrated with the twins’ fussiness, according to an affidavit. The discovery became significant because fussiness was also part of Straughter’s account of Kashan’s behavior before the emergency. The deleted messages did not, based on the reports reviewed, amount to a recorded confession. Prosecutors instead presented them as one element in a larger body of circumstantial evidence that included the medical findings, the timing of the injuries and the recovered home video.

By February 2024, the investigation had produced criminal charges. A Franklin County grand jury indicted Straughter on murder and child-endangerment counts, and police arrested her. At her arraignment, prosecuting attorney Scott Sugarman gave the court a preview of the medical evidence. He said the deputy coroner who conducted the autopsy described the swelling in Kashan’s brain as extraordinarily severe and believed the condition strongly suggested abusive head trauma from violent shaking. Kashan’s parents attended the hearing with supporters as the court established conditions for Straughter’s pretrial release.

The criminal case then moved slowly toward trial. The prosecution’s theory was that Straughter inflicted the injuries while Kashan was in her care. The defense had to confront a case in which no reported surveillance recording showed the fatal act. Pretrial litigation included a dispute over whether jurors could hear about surveillance footage involving Straughter’s treatment of a cat on the same day, according to reporting shortly before the verdict. Those evidentiary disputes illustrate how the trial was fought over what individual facts could legitimately tell jurors about the events inside the home.

When the case finally reached a Franklin County jury in August 2026, the central question was no longer whether Kashan had suffered fatal trauma; the coroner had classified the death as a homicide years earlier. The issue was whether prosecutors had proved beyond a reasonable doubt that Straughter was criminally responsible. The jurors returned guilty verdicts on Aug. 20 for both murder and endangering children, resolving that question against her. The conviction transformed allegations that had been repeated in court filings and hearings since 2024 into findings of guilt under criminal law.

At the sentencing hearing six weeks later, the chronology that had occupied investigators and lawyers gave way to the family’s account of what the three-year case had meant. Kashan’s father, Jontue Chatman, spoke about entrusting his children to Straughter and expecting them to be protected. Crawford told the court that she had lived with rage, heartbreak and unanswered questions. She said, however, that she did not want to use most of her statement to talk about Straughter, shifting attention back to the child whose death had brought everyone into the courtroom.

Kashan was born April 25, 2023, with his twin brother and died at 5 months and 18 days old. His obituary described a baby remembered for his smiles, expressive looks and affection. The criminal case could establish responsibility and punishment, but it could not answer every question his mother referenced at sentencing. Sperlazza’s judgment requires Straughter to serve a minimum of 15 years before she can be considered for parole; eligibility at that point does not guarantee that she will be released.

One sentencing-day report said Straughter’s defense had 30 days to file an appeal. A search of reliable reporting through Nov. 18 did not identify a subsequent decision changing the judgment. The case therefore stands, for now, at the point reached almost exactly three years after the first emergency: Straughter convicted of murder and child endangerment, Kashan’s death legally attributed to her conduct by a jury, and a life sentence in effect unless later court proceedings alter it.

Author note: Last updated Nov. 18, 2026.