Off duty cop strangled to death by cousin at Pennsylvania cabin during family gathering police say

Michael McGeehan was mourned as a veteran officer before an autopsy and witness statements led police to arrest Paden Frey.

MIDDLESEX TOWNSHIP, Pa. — When the Middlesex Township Police Department announced Officer Michael McGeehan’s death in July, colleagues remembered a trusted 12-year veteran, husband and father whose passing had been unexpected. Nearly three months later, authorities disclosed a different dimension to his death: investigators had classified it as a homicide and charged a 25-year-old man with murder.

The shift from memorial to criminal case followed an investigation more than 100 miles from the Cumberland County community where McGeehan worked. He died July 11 while off duty at a family gathering at a cabin in Cummings Township, Lycoming County. Police allege that Paden Edward Frey restrained McGeehan during a confrontation and pressed a forearm against his neck until McGeehan lost consciousness. Frey was arrested Oct. 7 and charged with third-degree murder, strangulation, involuntary manslaughter and recklessly endangering another person.

For McGeehan’s department, the charges arrived after months of mourning. Middlesex Township police had described him as an officer who served with professionalism, compassion and a strong commitment to the job. Chief Andrew Bassler later told WGAL that the homicide ruling surprised him. After learning more about the investigation, Bassler said the charges appeared consistent with the course authorities had taken based on what they learned. McGeehan was posthumously promoted to corporal.

McGeehan, 44, had been involved in law enforcement since 2001, according to Lycoming Regional Police. His obituary said he graduated from Northern High School in 2001 and later completed HACC’s Municipal Police Academy, where he served as president of his academy class. His family and department also emphasized the part of his life outside policing. He was married, had five sons and coached youth sports, including track and football. A memorial fundraiser established after his death focused on helping his wife and children cope with the sudden loss.

The criminal case, however, turns on events at the cabin rather than McGeehan’s career. Investigators say the gathering became tense after McGeehan consumed a large amount of alcohol. Witnesses told police that people at the cabin wanted him to go to bed and were concerned when he talked about swimming or taking a four-wheeler ride. Their effort to keep him from leaving became physical. According to the probable-cause affidavit, multiple people restrained McGeehan during a struggle on the porch.

McGeehan’s son gave investigators one of the most detailed accounts. He said Frey placed his forearm across the middle of McGeehan’s neck as another man held McGeehan’s arms, according to reporting based on the affidavit. He described his father as continuing to struggle and having difficulty breathing while pressure was maintained. The confrontation lasted about 10 minutes or longer, the son told investigators. Police say the encounter ended when McGeehan lost consciousness.

McGeehan’s wife witnessed another portion of the struggle. She told investigators that Frey yelled at her to get away while he was on top of McGeehan and said he would “put him to sleep” if McGeehan did not stop. Authorities allege Frey subsequently left McGeehan on the porch instead of providing aid. The affidavit says other witnesses also told investigators that Frey went inside after McGeehan became unresponsive.

A call to Lycoming County 911 came at about 2:38 a.m. Emergency-call statements quoted in reporting on the criminal complaint referred to people at the gathering having tried to put McGeehan to sleep because he was intoxicated and having choked him. Police and emergency medical personnel arrived at the Dam Run Road property at about 2:57 a.m. They found McGeehan on his back on the porch. He could not be revived and was pronounced dead.

Frey’s first account to investigators described a fight aimed at getting McGeehan to sleep but did not include what police later identified as the central act in the death. According to the affidavit, Frey told investigators that he and another person struggled with McGeehan and eventually got him to lie on the porch, where he fell asleep. Investigators said the statement did not disclose that Frey had applied pressure to McGeehan’s neck until McGeehan lost consciousness. That alleged omission became significant after police compared his account with witness interviews and the autopsy.

The autopsy was performed July 13, two days after the gathering. Authorities said it identified manual strangulation from forearm compression of the neck as the cause of death, and the Lycoming County Coroner’s Office ruled the manner of death a homicide. Reports describing the medical findings also cited blunt-force head injuries and health factors such as cardiovascular disease, obesity, sleep apnea and alcohol-related conditions. Investigators relied on the neck-compression finding when linking the death to the restraint described by witnesses.

After the autopsy, regional police and the coroner’s office continued a joint investigation. No arrest was announced through the summer. On Oct. 7, Lycoming Regional Police and sheriff’s deputies went to Frey’s Cogan Station residence and took him into custody without incident. The department said he was arraigned that day before Magisterial District Judge Denise Dieter. Frey was sent to Lycoming County Prison without bail. Later court-record reporting said the bail decision was based on a finding that no condition would adequately protect the community.

Third-degree murder is the most serious of the charges filed against Frey but does not allege the intentional killing required for Pennsylvania first-degree murder. State law defines third-degree murder as other forms of murder that do not fall within the first- or second-degree categories. Pennsylvania courts require proof of malice for a third-degree conviction, a legal standard that can be established through extremely reckless conduct undertaken in conscious disregard of a grave risk. Prosecutors have not yet proven that standard in Frey’s case, and he remains presumed innocent.

The separate strangulation charge requires its own proof. Pennsylvania law makes it an offense to knowingly or intentionally impede someone’s breathing or blood circulation by applying pressure to the throat or neck or blocking the nose and mouth. The Commonwealth’s allegations rely in part on the son’s description of Frey’s forearm position, statements that McGeehan was struggling to breathe and the coroner’s findings. Frey’s defense can challenge those accounts and the medical evidence in court.

The timing of the arrest meant that McGeehan’s colleagues and family learned of the criminal allegations after funeral and memorial arrangements had already taken place. His July obituary had described his death as unexpected and focused on his devotion to his family, law-enforcement work and friendships. The funeral was held July 17 in Carlisle. In the months afterward, the homicide determination added a pending legal process to what had begun as a period of private and departmental grief.

That process is still near its beginning. Frey’s preliminary hearing was originally placed on the calendar for Oct. 21 but was later moved to Dec. 23, according to court records reported by Daily Voice. The hearing will address whether the prosecution has enough evidence to hold the charges for further court proceedings, not whether Frey is guilty. As of Nov. 18, he remained in the Lycoming County Prison, and no trial date had been announced.

For Middlesex Township police, the legal proceedings now run alongside the department’s effort to preserve McGeehan’s legacy as an officer and father. For investigators in Lycoming County, the case remains a homicide prosecution centered on what happened during a short period on a cabin porch. The next scheduled court proceeding, barring another change, is Frey’s Dec. 23 preliminary hearing.

Author note: Last updated November 18, 2026.