Mother helped boyfriend hide 4-year-old son’s fatal beating behind bogus car crash story

The prosecution of Dominique Bailey and Kevin Spencer developed from a chain of physical, digital and witness evidence assembled over nearly three years.

PHILADELPHIA, Penn. — When city workers opened a black duffel bag in a West Philadelphia alley in March 2024, police could not immediately say whose badly decomposed remains were inside. Weeks later, DNA supplied a name: 4-year-old Damari Carter, a boy investigators had been searching for since the previous December.

The identification transformed one of the case’s most troubling pieces of evidence into a direct link in a homicide investigation. Prosecutors already had surveillance footage showing Kevin Spencer leave his apartment months earlier with a black Puma duffel bag. They also had recovered cellphone videos showing Damari injured shortly before he disappeared, recordings from a downstairs neighbor, and conflicting statements from Spencer and the child’s mother, Dominique Bailey. In October 2026, a jury found both defendants guilty of third-degree murder and related crimes. Their sentencing is scheduled for Dec. 4.

The bag was discovered March 18, 2024, by workers clearing an area behind the 600 block of North 38th Street in Philadelphia’s Mantua section. The remains had been exposed long enough that police initially could not establish the child’s identity. Authorities investigated whether the discovery might resolve the disappearance of Damari, who had been missing for months even though Bailey and Spencer had already been arrested in connection with his death. DNA testing eventually confirmed in May that the remains were his.

For investigators, the location and the container mattered because of evidence collected before the body was found. A hallway camera at Spencer’s apartment on Reno Street had recorded Damari entering the building on Dec. 5, 2023. Prosecutors said he never appeared on the camera again. On Dec. 8, Spencer was recorded leaving with a large trash bag. On Dec. 9, the video showed him leaving with a black Puma duffel bag. When Damari was found months later, prosecutors said his remains were inside a bag matching that description.

Other details tightened the connection. Prosecutors said Damari was wearing clothing that matched what he had on in cellphone footage from Dec. 7, including distinctive pants and a sweatshirt. A forensic review of Spencer’s phone recovered deleted videos that showed injuries to the boy’s head and face. At trial, the prosecution used the timing of those recordings alongside the hallway footage to argue that Damari was alive but injured on Dec. 7, disappeared from the apartment’s visible routine shortly afterward and was removed from the building in the bag later recovered with his remains.

The physical evidence did not stand alone. A downstairs neighbor told investigators that she heard Damari crying and sounds she believed were repeated beatings during the first week of December. She made recordings and contacted the city’s Department of Human Services on Dec. 7. Prosecutors said at a preliminary hearing that the agency apparently did not intervene before the child died. A city official later said Damari was not in DHS custody or receiving services and cited state confidentiality law in declining to release more information about the agency’s handling of the report.

Prosecutors placed that evidence against the background of Damari’s move into Spencer’s home. Bailey and the boy had come to Philadelphia from Texas and initially lived with her father. Damari was developmentally delayed and nonverbal, and his grandfather helped care for him, according to the District Attorney’s Office. After Bailey’s father confronted her over concerns that she was leaving the boy alone, prosecutors said, she moved out with Damari and began staying with Spencer. The child’s relatives last heard from him around his fourth birthday in late November.

What followed created a second evidence trail built not around cameras or DNA, but statements. Bailey told relatives that Damari had died after being struck by a vehicle. Her family could not verify the story and became increasingly alarmed when they did not see the boy. They circulated missing-person information and contacted local media. On Dec. 30, the Philadelphia Police Department’s Special Victims Unit began investigating after a news outlet alerted officers to Damari’s disappearance.

Detectives checked the most basic parts of Bailey’s account. Prosecutors said they contacted hospitals, the medical examiner’s office and the Crash Investigation Unit and found no record of a traffic collision or death involving a 4-year-old matching Damari. When Bailey was questioned Jan. 4, 2024, she first said she had been walking with the child when he dropped a toy and was hit near 40th Street and Lancaster Avenue. She later told police that Spencer had been the person walking with Damari.

Spencer initially denied knowing the boy, according to prosecutors. He then supplied a similar crash account. Both defendants claimed that an ambulance had transported Damari to Children’s Hospital of Philadelphia and that the hospital had lost his body after he died. Investigators found no evidence that this occurred. They searched the Reno Street apartment and found neither the boy nor children’s belongings. Those contradictions became significant at trial because prosecutors argued the false accounts showed a coordinated effort to conceal Damari’s actual death.

Bailey and Spencer were arrested in January, before the discovery of Damari’s remains. At that stage, authorities believed the child was dead but still lacked his body. The March discovery and subsequent DNA identification filled that gap. The medical examiner later determined that Damari died of homicidal violence. The examination documented injuries, while the prosecution’s digital evidence offered a timeline leading into the period when investigators believed he died. Together, prosecutors argued, the evidence demonstrated far more than an unexplained disappearance.

The defense attacked the chain at several points. Spencer’s attorney argued that nobody had directly witnessed either defendant beating Damari and challenged the reliability of conclusions drawn from sounds recorded by the downstairs neighbor. He also questioned whether the prosecution could establish precisely what happened inside the apartment from circumstantial evidence. Bailey’s defense sought to distinguish her conduct from Spencer’s, arguing that she was away when the fatal violence occurred and that the neighbor’s testimony placed many of the troubling sounds during periods when Bailey was at work.

Bailey’s attorney also offered a different interpretation of her conduct after Damari’s disappearance. Rather than treating every inconsistency in her statements as proof of a deliberate cover-up, the defense argued that confusion and her relationship with Spencer affected her responses to investigators. The prosecution countered that the false accident story was not a momentary mistake because versions of it were given to relatives and police, while physical and digital evidence pointed to an entirely different sequence inside the Reno Street apartment.

The jury did not adopt the prosecution’s case in full. Bailey and Spencer were both acquitted of first-degree murder, an outcome that rejected the highest degree of homicide placed before jurors. But they were convicted of third-degree murder, conspiracy to commit murder, endangering the welfare of a child, criminal use of a communication facility, false reports to law enforcement, tampering with evidence and abuse of a corpse. The combination of verdicts showed that jurors distinguished between proof of murder and the additional findings necessary for a first-degree conviction.

That distinction is particularly important in a case built heavily from circumstantial evidence. No single camera captured the entire crime. No witness testified to seeing the fatal act itself. Instead, prosecutors assembled the case through multiple points that converged: Damari’s final appearance on hallway video, sounds recorded by a neighbor, injuries visible in cellphone footage, the defendants’ unsupported traffic-crash story, Spencer’s movement of bags from the apartment, the later discovery of the duffel bag, the clothing found with Damari and the medical examiner’s homicide determination.

The sequence also explains why the case unfolded in stages rather than through one immediate discovery. In December 2023, relatives knew mainly that Damari was gone and that the account of his death did not make sense. In January 2024, investigators had enough evidence to make arrests but still had no body. In March, workers unexpectedly found unidentified remains. In May, DNA confirmed Damari’s identity. More than two years later, jurors were asked to consider how those separate discoveries fit together and what they established about Bailey’s and Spencer’s criminal responsibility.

The next stage will be punishment and any post-trial litigation. Covington is scheduled to sentence both defendants on Dec. 4, 2026. Spencer’s lawyer said after the verdict that his client had asked him to appeal. The records and reporting reviewed for this article do not establish what specific sentence either defendant will receive, and no sentence should be assumed before the hearing. For now, the evidence trail that began with a missing child and ended with DNA identification has produced convictions, while the final judgments and any appeals remain ahead.

Author note: Last updated November 17, 2026.