Relatives described recent psychiatric treatment for Francis Cabello, but no public record reviewed establishes whether illness caused the alleged killing.
NEW YORK, N.Y. — Within hours of 5-year-old Fabiana Cabello’s death, her family was confronting two crises at once: the loss of a child and questions about the mental health of the mother whom police would soon accuse of killing her.
Francis Cabello, 32, was charged with murder after Fabiana was found unconscious in the family’s Richmond Hill home on Oct. 14 and died at Jamaica Hospital Medical Center. Cabello’s father, Franklin Cabello, later told reporters that his daughter had struggled with mental health problems, had recently spent time in psychiatric care and, in his understanding, had stopped taking medication. Francis Cabello was also taken for a psychiatric evaluation after police responded to the home. Those facts have become a prominent part of public discussion surrounding the case. They do not, however, establish why Fabiana died, whether a particular condition affected Cabello at the time or what legal significance her health history may ultimately have.
The distinction between family recollection and verified medical evidence is central to understanding the case. Franklin Cabello told CBS New York that his daughter had spent time in a psychiatric ward and later said she was no longer taking her medication. NBC New York reported that he believed she had been home for about two months after a hospitalization and that he had noticed behavior that concerned him. NY1 similarly reported his account that she had stopped medication after saying a doctor told her she could do so. No medical records reviewed by the news organizations publicly established the medication involved, the diagnosis, the doctor’s instructions or the nature of Cabello’s condition. The family’s statements therefore provide context, not a clinical conclusion.
Fabiana’s father, Kuldeep Singh, said he had understood the situation differently. Singh and Cabello were estranged but communicated as co-parents. He told Gothamist that he was unaware of mental health problems that caused him to worry about his daughter’s safety. He also said Cabello cared for Fabiana. Their messages, Singh said, included discussions about supplies for Fabiana’s first year of kindergarten. The child asked for a pink schoolbag and shoes. That ordinary family correspondence stands in sharp contrast to what police say happened on Oct. 14, but it also shows why relatives’ descriptions cannot be arranged into a simple warning-sign narrative after the fact.
Police say the immediate evidence began with Cabello herself. Authorities reported that she called 911 shortly before 7 p.m. and told the dispatcher, “I killed my daughter.” When officers arrived, Cabello was downstairs and allegedly said Fabiana was upstairs and not breathing. Officers found the girl unconscious and unresponsive in a bedroom and rushed her to Jamaica Hospital Medical Center. She was pronounced dead. Franklin Cabello, who was at the home, said he had not seen what happened inside the closed room. Police arrested his daughter the following evening.
The criminal complaint added medical findings to the statements attributed to Cabello. According to reports describing the complaint, a doctor from the Office of the Chief Medical Examiner found facial scrapes and petechiae in Fabiana’s eyes, heart and lungs. The complaint said such findings can occur in cases of asphyxia. ABC7 reported that prosecutors raised the possibility that Fabiana had been strangled, while other early reports stressed that her exact cause of death remained under further study. Those details support the existence of a homicide investigation and prosecution, but they do not justify stating a mechanism of death more definitively than the medical record available publicly at the time.
Cabello appeared in Queens Criminal Court on Oct. 16 before Judge Jennifer Saint-Preux and was ordered held without bail. CBS New York reported that she faced a second-degree murder charge. Her father stood outside the courthouse and asked that her mental health be taken into consideration. The request reflected the family’s concern, but no published source reviewed for this article established that Cabello had raised a formal psychiatric defense, had been found incompetent to proceed or had undergone a court-ordered examination resulting in a public finding. Mental illness and legal responsibility are not interchangeable concepts, and a relative’s description of illness does not decide whether a defendant can be held criminally responsible.
The same caution applies to public debate about whether the health system failed the family. At an Oct. 20 vigil for Fabiana, some community members expressed concern about the mental-health services available to Cabello and her relatives. One attendee told Spectrum News NY1 that Cabello had voluntarily sought help and argued that the system had failed her. That was an opinion voiced at a vigil, not a finding by investigators or a review board. The available reports did not establish what services Cabello received, what follow-up care was offered, whether she followed treatment recommendations or whether any provider knew of an immediate danger to Fabiana.
The Administration for Children’s Services also said it was investigating the tragedy with the NYPD. Its statement did not disclose previous involvement with the family. Public reports reviewed for this article did not show whether ACS had an open case, had received prior complaints or had ever been asked to assess Fabiana’s safety before Oct. 14. Without that information, assigning institutional blame would go beyond the verified record. The agency investigation matters because it may clarify whether any child-welfare history existed, but the fact of an investigation after a child’s death does not itself prove earlier knowledge or failure.
Amid those questions, Fabiana’s relatives tried to keep attention on the child rather than only on the circumstances of her death. Her grandfather described her as intelligent and said she was learning English and Spanish. Singh remembered the affection she showed him and the school items she wanted. Neighbors recalled seeing her playing outside, riding a bicycle or scooter and interacting with other children during the summer. At the vigil, Singh called her his princess. Those memories are relevant because mental-health discussions about an accused parent can easily push the victim to the edge of the narrative even though Fabiana’s death is the reason every investigation and court proceeding exists.
The family’s public comments also reveal a tension that the court will not resolve in emotional terms. Relatives have said Francis Cabello loved and cared for Fabiana. Prosecutors accuse her of causing the girl’s death. Both statements can appear in the same public record without one being used to erase the other. A history of caregiving does not disprove a criminal allegation. Likewise, a murder charge does not authorize reporters or the public to invent a motive, diagnosis or state of mind that prosecutors have not established. The legal case turns on evidence about what happened and the mental state required by the charged offense, not on whether relatives regarded Cabello as a loving mother before Oct. 14.
There are also limits to what can be concluded from the 911 call. The statement attributed to Cabello is plainly important evidence because police say she directly implicated herself. But a reported confession outside court does not eliminate the need for the prosecution to prove its case. Lawyers may litigate the circumstances surrounding statements, medical findings and other evidence. The defense may also present information not yet public. Cabello is therefore properly described as accused of murder even though the reported emergency call is unusually direct.
Reliable sources reviewed through Nov. 21 did not clearly document a final resolution of the case, a final public medical determination or the result of the Oct. 20 return date listed in early coverage. That leaves the central questions in different hands: medical examiners must establish the forensic findings, investigators must assemble evidence, and the courts must determine criminal responsibility. Family members can describe Cabello’s health history and Fabiana’s life, but those accounts cannot substitute for either process. For now, the verified record supports a murder accusation, a grieving family and substantial unanswered questions about what preceded the death of a 5-year-old girl.
Author note: Last updated November 21, 2026.