Kourtney Aumen’s case moved from mental-competency litigation toward a jury trial before an October plea abruptly changed its course.
WARSAW, Mo. — A Missouri murder prosecution that spent part of 2026 focused on whether Kourtney Aumen was competent to stand trial ended its fact-finding phase in a different way: Aumen pleaded guilty to second-degree murder and first-degree assault in the 2020 death of 4-year-old Jessica Mast.
The plea on Oct. 5 followed a concentrated stretch of courtroom activity in which Aumen was found competent, unsuccessfully sought to waive a jury and remained scheduled for a five-day trial beginning Oct. 26. Instead of asking jurors to determine whether prosecutors had proved the charges, Aumen admitted guilt. Her next scheduled proceeding is no longer a trial but a Dec. 21 sentencing hearing, where the court will determine punishment.
The competency dispute that preceded the plea had become a central procedural issue. Aumen had previously been found competent, but her defense raised renewed concerns in 2026 and argued that she should be in the custody of the Missouri Department of Mental Health. A defense filing reported by local media said a doctor had determined during a July evaluation that Aumen was not competent at that time. Her lawyers argued that treatment in a hospital setting was necessary and raised concerns about deterioration in her mental condition.
By September, however, the court again found Aumen competent to proceed. The finding did not mean that her attorneys believed communication problems had disappeared. In a filing after the ruling, the defense said counsel continued to face profound difficulty communicating with Aumen and preparing parts of the case with her assistance. Legally, though, the competency determination allowed the prosecution to continue toward trial rather than remain stalled while her ability to participate in the proceedings was addressed.
The distinction matters because competency is not the same question as criminal guilt. A competency determination addresses whether a defendant can proceed through the court process under the applicable legal standard; it does not decide whether that person committed the charged offenses. Once the judge found Aumen competent, prosecutors still would have been required to prove their criminal case at trial unless it was otherwise resolved. Aumen’s eventual guilty plea supplied that resolution without a jury verdict.
A separate dispute then emerged over who would decide the case. Aumen attempted to waive a jury trial in September, but Webster County Circuit Judge M. Brandon Baker declined to accept the request. The judge cited the seriousness of the charges, according to an order reported by local media. That left the October jury trial in place. Yet within days, the anticipated courtroom contest changed again when a change-of-plea hearing appeared on the docket and Aumen admitted guilt to two serious felony offenses.
Those 2026 procedural battles came years after the events underlying the prosecution. Benton County deputies responded to Jessica’s family home on Dec. 20, 2020, after receiving a report of a possible domestic disturbance. They found the 4-year-old dead. Authorities said she had suffered severe physical abuse and had been repeatedly immersed in a cold pond. A 2-year-old boy and Jessica’s mother also had been injured, according to investigators. An infant in the home was reported unharmed.
The investigation led authorities to Aumen and Ethan Mast, who lived near the family. Officials have repeatedly said Ethan Mast was not related to Jessica’s parents despite sharing their surname. Jessica’s father, James Mast, told investigators that the neighbors had harmed his family and threatened the parents if they tried to intervene. Statements gathered during the investigation also referred to a supposed “demon,” and Sheriff Eric Knox described the episode publicly as having a religious character.
Authorities did not limit their investigation to the two neighbors. Both of Jessica’s parents were charged as well, creating a group of related prosecutions that proceeded at different speeds. Ethan Mast pleaded guilty in 2022 to second-degree murder and assault. Mary Mast later pleaded guilty to endangering the welfare of a child. James Mast pleaded guilty in 2024 to second-degree murder and first-degree assault but subsequently sought to withdraw his plea, leading to additional litigation over whether it would stand.
Aumen’s case, meanwhile, remained unresolved and ultimately moved from Benton County to Webster County on a change of venue. As prosecutors prepared for trial, her competency became a repeated subject of court review. Local reporting shows that she had been found competent before the renewed 2026 dispute. Defense lawyers later said she had numerous medications and argued that her mental health required a higher level of treatment than she was receiving in jail. Those claims affected the timing and preparation of the case but did not themselves dispose of the criminal charges.
That is why the October plea marks such a sharp procedural break. Had Aumen gone to trial, jurors would have heard the evidence, received instructions from the judge and been asked to determine guilt on the charges placed before them. Her defense would have had the opportunity to challenge the prosecution’s witnesses and evidence. The plea removed the need for that process on the offenses she admitted, shifting the court’s task from deciding whether she committed those crimes to determining the consequences of her admitted guilt.
The change also narrowed the questions reporters and the public can responsibly answer now. The record supports reporting that Aumen pleaded guilty to second-degree murder and first-degree assault and that sentencing is set for Dec. 21. It does not support treating the sentence as known in advance. Nor should the plea be used to erase the differing legal positions of the other three defendants, whose cases have included separate admissions, charges and post-plea proceedings.
The underlying facts remain stark even without graphic detail. Investigators said Jessica suffered repeated abuse before her death, while other members of her household were also hurt. Law enforcement accounts said she was taken into cold water during winter conditions. Deputies arriving at the home found her dead. Those findings prompted arrests, years of court proceedings and strong public reaction in Benton County, including a vigil and efforts to support first responders who had dealt with the scene.
The community response never replaced the legal safeguards governing the prosecution. Competency reviews, venue changes, plea hearings and decisions about trial format can make a criminal case appear slow or fragmented, but each serves a distinct role. In Aumen’s prosecution, those processes took on unusual prominence during the final months before the plea. Her case moved in a matter of weeks from uncertainty about whether she could proceed, to preparation for trial, to a request for a judge rather than a jury, and finally to an admission of guilt.
That sequence leaves sentencing as the central unresolved issue in Aumen’s case. The Dec. 21 hearing is scheduled to take place after nearly six years of investigation and litigation following Jessica’s death. Until the judge enters sentence, the punishment remains undecided, even though the question of Aumen’s guilt on the two plea offenses has been resolved by her own admission in court.
Author note: Last updated November 17, 2026.