The judge’s decision to stack Randy Zimmerman’s two life sentences became the final major issue after his first-degree murder pleas.
NEW ULM, Minn. — Randy Thomas Zimmerman was already certain to receive life imprisonment when he entered Brown County District Court for sentencing. The unresolved question was how two mandatory life terms would be arranged — together or consecutively — for the killings of Tabitha Trescott and Justin Reinarts.
The court chose consecutive sentences on Oct. 5, 2026, a decision that became the defining feature of the punishment. Zimmerman, 46, had pleaded guilty in August to two first-degree murder counts, each carrying a life term with the possibility of eventual release consideration. A concurrent sentence would have allowed the two terms to run at the same time. Consecutive sentences make them follow one another. Trescott’s family had urged the latter approach, saying it better reflected two separate deaths and reduced the prospect that Zimmerman could return to the community after serving the minimum period associated with a single life term.
Minnesota law provides the framework behind that dispute. First-degree murder is punishable by life imprisonment. For several categories of first-degree murder, state law bars supervised release consideration until an inmate has served at least 30 years. Release is not automatic at that point; the state’s supervised-release process still determines whether an eligible inmate is actually released. Other forms of first-degree murder can carry life without release. In Zimmerman’s case, premeditated murder counts with that more severe potential were dismissed under the plea agreement, while the two convictions he accepted remained life sentences that allow a future possibility of release under the applicable rules.
The plea agreement therefore narrowed the case but did not make sentencing routine. Zimmerman admitted two different forms of first-degree murder. For Reinarts’ death, court documents said he acknowledged entering the home without permission while armed with a dangerous weapon and intentionally killing Reinarts, supporting murder committed during burglary. For Trescott’s death, Zimmerman admitted intentionally killing a former romantic partner after a past pattern of domestic abuse. The state, in return, agreed to move for dismissal of the other charges that had been returned by a grand jury, including premeditated first-degree murder, second-degree murder, burglary and assault counts.
That bargain also removed the need for a jury to hear the prosecution’s full evidence. Before the plea, the case had been set up to involve a child witness, prior domestic-abuse records, evidence from the Hanska residence and the circumstances of Zimmerman’s arrest in Iowa. Trescott’s mother, Terri Smith, said she valued one consequence of the plea in particular: her grandson would not have to recount the killings from a witness stand. At the same time, she opposed any outcome she believed could shorten the period before possible release. Those two concerns — protecting a child from trial testimony and maximizing the sentence — pulled in different directions until the judge ordered the terms to run consecutively.
The factual basis for the convictions reaches back to the early morning of Nov. 2, 2025. Authorities said Zimmerman entered the Hanska home where Trescott, 32, was living with Reinarts, 50. Trescott’s 13-year-old son told investigators he awoke to yelling and then heard a gunshot. The criminal complaint said the boy opened his door and encountered Zimmerman in a hallway with a long gun. Investigators said Zimmerman pointed the weapon toward him and ordered him back into the room. The child later called 911 and reported that his mother’s former boyfriend had broken into the house and shot her.
When deputies arrived, they found Trescott and Reinarts dead in the home. Investigators recovered spent shotgun shells upstairs. The later guilty plea established Zimmerman’s intentional killing of both victims, avoiding the need to treat the complaint’s allegations as the final word on criminal responsibility. That procedural distinction matters because the public record developed in layers: the first complaint described what law enforcement believed had happened, the grand jury indictment expanded the charges, and the August 2026 plea finally set out the conduct Zimmerman personally admitted as the basis for two first-degree murder convictions.
The history between Zimmerman and Trescott supplied an additional layer that did not exist in the Reinarts count. KEYC reported that Zimmerman had misdemeanor domestic assault convictions involving Trescott from December 2023 and December 2024. Court records also showed a pending felony stalking case tied to a July 2025 incident in which Trescott was identified as the alleged victim. Prosecutors relied on a past pattern of domestic abuse as an element of the first-degree murder charge involving her. The result was a sentence that punished two killings under separate legal theories rather than treating them as identical counts arising from the same set of facts.
Zimmerman’s flight after the killings widened the case beyond Brown County. Authorities said he drove into Iowa as law enforcement agencies searched for him. During a pursuit, an Iowa sheriff said Zimmerman fired a shotgun backward from his vehicle toward a deputy. The deputy was not hit. Officers from Louisa, Washington and Muscatine counties and the Iowa State Patrol became involved before Zimmerman’s vehicle was forced off the road. He was arrested after a foot pursuit, about 12 hours after the 911 call in Hanska. Those Iowa allegations were separate from the Minnesota murder convictions that produced the life sentences.
The grand jury’s November 2025 indictment had placed Zimmerman at risk of an even harsher formal outcome. It contained nine felony counts, among them two first-degree premeditated murder charges. Under Minnesota law, certain first-degree premeditated murder convictions require life imprisonment without the possibility of release. By pleading guilty to the felony-murder count for Reinarts and the domestic-abuse-pattern count for Trescott, Zimmerman avoided trial on the premeditated counts. The plea did not guarantee that his two life terms would overlap, however, and prosecutors left the sequencing decision to the court.
At sentencing, Zimmerman expressed remorse and said he hoped the proceeding would provide some closure. Reinarts’ son Austin described the result to KEYC as the “best case scenario,” while also saying even that outcome was not truly a good one. The families’ statements underscored why the legal victory felt limited. Reinarts was remembered as a volunteer firefighter with deep local ties. Trescott was remembered by relatives as compassionate and energetic, and she left two sons. Both families had spent nearly a year waiting to learn not only whether Zimmerman would be convicted, but what the final sentencing structure would mean.
The case also became part of a broader public conversation about intimate-partner violence in Minnesota. Violence Free Minnesota included Trescott in its 2025 memorial of confirmed intimate-partner homicide victims. Local reporting noted that she had recently moved in with Reinarts and that Zimmerman’s earlier convictions involving her were already part of the court record before the murders. Those facts are relevant not because they explain every motive or decision — prosecutors did not need to establish a speculative psychological account — but because the past abuse was an element of the first-degree murder offense to which Zimmerman pleaded guilty.
KEYC reported that Zimmerman received credit for 345 days already served and that the sentence would be carried out through the Minnesota correctional system. The court also left a 30-day window for restitution to be finalized for the victims’ families. No later public report reviewed for this story supplied a final restitution amount. With the prison terms imposed, the principal criminal questions have been resolved: Zimmerman admitted the two killings, prosecutors dismissed the remaining counts under the agreement, and the judge ordered the life sentences to run consecutively rather than concurrently.
That sequencing decision is the case’s final legal marker as of Nov. 17. The plea determined guilt and fixed life imprisonment as the basic punishment; sentencing determined how those two life terms would interact. For the families of Trescott and Reinarts, the court chose the structure they had asked for. It does not restore the two people killed in Hanska or end the effects on their children, but it settles the question left open when Zimmerman pleaded guilty: the two murders will be reflected in separate, consecutive life sentences.
Author note: Last updated November 17, 2026.