Terry Jefferson admitted shooting Charles Williams but said he believed the friend helping him move was reaching for his handgun.
MILWAUKEE, Wis. — Terry Jefferson acknowledged from the beginning that he fired the shots that killed Charles Williams. The central dispute in the Milwaukee homicide case was why: Jefferson said he feared Williams was trying to take his handgun, while the evidence presented through the investigation described an unarmed man wounded during two separate rounds of gunfire.
A jury resolved that dispute in July by finding Jefferson guilty of first-degree intentional homicide. On Oct. 8, Milwaukee County Judge Laura Crivello sentenced him to life in prison, with eligibility for release to extended supervision after 35 years. The punishment closed the trial phase of a case that began Feb. 26, 2025, when Williams was helping Jefferson move possessions into an apartment near North 27th Street and West Highland Avenue.
Jefferson’s explanation to detectives began with the gun he was carrying that afternoon. He said the weapon was in the pocket of his hooded sweatshirt and that Williams knew it was there. Williams had been helping him unload his vehicle, and the two used a shopping cart to carry belongings into the building. Jefferson said he took the elevator and encountered Williams at close range when the doors opened. Williams then started grabbing near the items, Jefferson told police.
Jefferson said he believed that movement was directed toward the handgun. He pulled out the weapon and fired once, believing he struck Williams in the face. According to the criminal complaint, Jefferson knew Williams had been hit because he saw him bleeding. He told Williams to remain down. What Jefferson did not tell detectives was that he had seen a weapon in Williams’ hands; to the contrary, he acknowledged during the interview that he never saw Williams with a gun or another weapon.
The events after that first shot became especially significant because the shooting did not end there. Jefferson said his handgun malfunctioned and that he had to clear the problem. A resident nearby heard the initial shot and came into the hallway, where the witness saw Williams on the floor and Jefferson holding a black semiautomatic handgun. Jefferson made statements indicating Williams had shot himself and had tried to grab Jefferson’s gun, according to the complaint.
Jefferson asked the resident to call for medical help. The witness contacted 911, and Jefferson took the phone during part of the call. Williams was still attempting to move or rise after being wounded, according to the resident. The witness then went back into the apartment. From inside, the resident heard another six or seven gunshots fired quickly. The later burst occurred after the witness had already seen Williams down and after a call for emergency assistance had begun.
Investigators received a 22-second doorbell-camera clip documenting part of the gap between the shootings. Court records said the recording showed Jefferson standing over Williams while Williams remained on the hallway floor. Williams was not moving during the portion recorded, according to the complaint. The camera did not capture every part of the confrontation, but the clip supported the resident’s account of the scene that existed before the witness retreated and heard the later gunshots.
A second resident told detectives that Williams was on his knees near the elevator and reaching toward the shopping cart that contained belongings from the move. That witness described Jefferson as telling Williams to stay down while working the slide of his handgun. The resident then saw Jefferson fire more shots. The witness did not see Williams holding a weapon. The account provided investigators with an observation of Williams’ movements that differed from the threat Jefferson said he believed he was facing.
Jefferson’s own demonstration during the police interview added another point of comparison. He placed Williams about one to two feet away when the first shot was fired. By the time of the later shots, Jefferson indicated Williams was not close enough to simply reach out and touch him, though Jefferson still characterized Williams as being in his personal space. Jefferson also said that after the second round of shooting began, Williams moved backward while still facing him before going down.
The physical scene was consistent with multiple rounds being fired. Investigators recovered eight spent .45-caliber cartridge casings from the hallway and a black Taurus .45-caliber handgun near the location where Jefferson was arrested. Officers had found Jefferson standing only feet from Williams with the handgun still in his right hand. They ordered him to drop it, and he complied. Police then turned their attention to Williams, providing aid before he was taken to a hospital.
Williams was pronounced dead at the hospital, and an autopsy determined that he died from multiple gunshot wounds. The quick arrival of officers was not the result of a normal dispatch from elsewhere in the city. Police were already inside the building that afternoon searching for a wanted person on an unrelated matter. An officer first heard a loud bang that could have been mistaken for a door closing, followed several minutes later by the unmistakable sound of rapid gunfire elsewhere in the property.
Jefferson also described an action he took after Williams was wounded that illustrated how the ordinary moving job continued to figure into the investigation. He told detectives that when he saw Williams bleeding after the first shot, he moved the shopping cart so the blood would not get on his possessions. Williams had been helping move those same belongings minutes earlier. The cart later appeared in a witness account of Williams reaching toward it while wounded near the elevator.
Prosecutors charged Jefferson with first-degree intentional homicide using a dangerous weapon. At his initial appearance on March 2, 2025, cash bond was set at $200,000. The case ultimately turned not on whether Jefferson fired the gun, which he admitted, but on whether his explanation legally justified the killing. His account emphasized a perceived effort by Williams to get the firearm. The other evidence included his admission that he never actually saw a weapon in Williams’ possession.
By finding Jefferson guilty in July 2026, the jury rejected the defense position and concluded that he was criminally responsible for Williams’ death. The verdict moved the case into sentencing, where Wisconsin’s life-sentence structure left the court to determine Jefferson’s eligibility for future release. Crivello imposed life imprisonment and set 35 years as the time Jefferson must serve before he can become eligible to leave prison on extended supervision.
The sentence does not mean Jefferson will automatically be released at the end of that period. It establishes when release can first become possible under the judgment. Until then, the conviction and sentence keep him imprisoned for a killing that began with a claimed fear over a gun and ended after multiple additional shots in an apartment hallway. The case record does not establish that Williams ever possessed a weapon during the encounter.
For Williams, the events began with an act of assistance to a friend. He had gone to help Jefferson transport possessions into a new apartment and was using the same elevator and shopping cart that later became part of the criminal investigation. For Jefferson, the case now carries a life sentence and a minimum of 35 years before release to extended supervision may be considered. The jury’s verdict stands as the legal rejection of his claim that the fatal shooting was justified.
Author note: Last updated November 20, 2026.