Love triangle erupts in murder after man follows musician to his car in Memphis

The murder trial of Edward Wurl paired an unusually short jury deliberation with extensive video, phone and social-media evidence assembled by prosecutors.

MEMPHIS, Tenn. — The jury’s work took about eight minutes. Getting the case to the jury required prosecutors to sort through at least 18,000 individual evidence items before Edward “Eddie” Wurl was convicted of murdering Memphis musician Blake Rhea and later sentenced to a 60-year life term.

The sharp contrast between those two numbers became one of the defining features of the case. The Shelby County District Attorney’s Office said chief prosecutor Atina Stavropoulos, Assistant District Attorney Missy Branham and their team reviewed evidence from multiple phones, conducted frame-by-frame analysis of surveillance footage and prepared an enlarged video montage for trial. The collective exhibits presented in court contained at least 18,000 individual items. After that material was presented and Wurl testified in his own defense, jurors convicted him of first-degree murder and being a convicted felon in possession of a handgun after only a few minutes of deliberation.

The evidence was designed to give jurors several ways to examine the same sequence rather than depend on one witness’s recollection. Surveillance cameras documented the confrontation outside Louis Connelly’s bar. Phone data supplied records from before the killing. Facebook records showed repeated activity involving Rhea’s profile. Police reports established what officers encountered when they arrived. Wurl’s decision to testify added his own courtroom account. The public releases do not contain the full trial transcript, so they cannot show precisely how every item was introduced or challenged, but they outline a prosecution based on several different forms of evidence.

Rhea was killed during the early morning of Nov. 6, 2024. Officers responding shortly after 1 a.m. to South Cleveland Street found the 48-year-old musician in his parked vehicle with gunshot wounds and cuts. He was pronounced dead at the scene. Investigators said a verbal altercation between Rhea and Wurl had taken place inside the bar before the men moved outside. Early reports based on an affidavit also said police believed the two men had recently been romantically involved with the same woman. Prosecutors did not later identify that circumstance as the proven motive, leaving the precise reason for the fatal confrontation unresolved in the public record.

The surveillance recording supplied prosecutors with a visual account after Rhea left the bar area. According to the district attorney’s office, Wurl followed Rhea across the street toward his vehicle while holding something behind his back. Authorities said the object appeared consistent with a knife. At the vehicle, Wurl leaned through the open driver’s-side door and appeared to struggle with Rhea. He then backed away and raised his right hand. The recording captured several flashes that prosecutors described as consistent with gunfire. Wurl then walked away. Police arrived later and found Rhea inside the vehicle.

Other evidence asked jurors to look further back in time. Facebook records showed Wurl repeatedly accessing Rhea’s profile in the months before the killing, the district attorney’s office said. Separately, investigators found an internet search on Wurl’s phone from about a week before the homicide asking whether a gun that had not been fired for years would still work. The sources reviewed do not identify who physically typed that search, making the careful formulation important: it was evidence recovered from Wurl’s phone. Prosecutors placed those digital records alongside the video rather than presenting them as proof detached from the events outside the bar.

The volume of evidence also created a practical challenge for the prosecution. Thousands of individual items could easily overwhelm jurors if presented without a clear chronology. According to the district attorney’s office, prosecutors worked through recordings and device records to organize the case into a sequence jurors could follow. The enlarged video montage was one method of presenting surveillance footage in a more accessible form. The prosecution’s public statements do not identify all 18,000 items individually, and the figure should not be read as meaning jurors separately reviewed every item during deliberations. It describes the scale of the collective exhibits assembled for the case.

Wurl’s testimony meant jurors also heard directly from the defendant before deciding the case. Branham cross-examined him for the prosecution. Public summaries released after the verdict do not reproduce his complete testimony or provide a detailed account of the defense’s closing argument, so it is not possible from those sources to say exactly which defense claims jurors rejected. What can be stated is the result: they returned guilty verdicts on both charged counts after deliberating for roughly eight minutes. The district attorney’s office announced the convictions in October, nearly two years after Rhea’s death.

The brevity of the deliberation did not reveal what happened inside the jury room. Jurors do not have to explain how they weighed individual exhibits, which witness they found most persuasive or whether one piece of evidence decided the case for them. The eight-minute figure therefore measures only the time between receiving the case and returning the verdict. It does not establish that any single phone search, video frame or social-media record independently determined the outcome. The conviction reflects the jury’s assessment of the prosecution’s evidence as a whole after the trial had concluded.

About a month later, the case reached sentencing. Action News 5 reported, based on court records, that Criminal Court Judge Lee V. Coffee imposed life imprisonment with the possibility of parole. The district attorney’s office subsequently announced the punishment as 60 years. Tennessee’s sentencing statutes explain the apparent difference in terminology. State law treats a life sentence for first-degree murder as a 60-year term and separately regulates release eligibility and sentence credits. For a murder committed after July 1, 2024, those provisions impose specific conditions on how the sentence is served. The reviewed sources do not specify a separate sentence for Wurl’s firearm conviction.

District Attorney Steve Mulroy used the sentencing announcement to focus on the amount of preparation behind the conviction. He said the prosecutors had to review and organize thousands of pieces of evidence so the jury could understand the events. That comment placed the eight-minute deliberation in a different context. Jurors may have reached their decision quickly, but the case they received had been developed through a prolonged investigation and trial preparation process. The district attorney’s statements do not disclose every investigative step, but they document a record that included multiple digital devices, detailed video work and Wurl’s testimony.

The courtroom focus on evidence represented only one side of Rhea’s public story. He was a veteran bassist who performed with Southern Avenue, a Grammy-nominated Memphis group, and spent decades working in the city’s music community. His obituary said he toured throughout the United States and Europe and joined Southern Avenue on Willie Nelson’s Outlaw Music Festival tour in 2024, alongside a lineup that included Bob Dylan and John Mellencamp. He also performed at Farm Aid. His career included work with other bands and musicians, making him a familiar presence across parts of the Memphis scene well before his death became the subject of a murder prosecution.

Rhea was also a teacher at School of Rock, where his influence extended to younger musicians who had not yet built professional careers of their own. His obituary said he taught hundreds of children and noted that some former students later became instructors themselves. A memorial concert held after his killing featured former bandmates and young musicians who had studied with him. Friends described someone who paired musicianship with humor and encouragement. Those remembrances stood apart from the legal case, which necessarily concentrated on the final hours of his life and the evidence establishing who killed him.

The conviction and sentence now leave a record with two very different scales of time. Prosecutors spent months preparing a case from a homicide that occurred almost two years before trial. They organized thousands of exhibits and examined surveillance video one frame at a time. Jurors then needed about eight minutes to decide the charged offenses. The contrast is dramatic, but the two measurements describe different parts of the process: one reflects the work required to investigate and present a complex case, while the other reflects how long jurors needed after hearing it.

For the court system, the central questions have now been answered. Wurl was convicted of first-degree murder and illegal handgun possession, and a sentence has been entered. He is subject to the life term described by the district attorney as 60 years, and no additional trial-level proceeding was identified in the reviewed sources. For Rhea’s community, the evidence record is not the only record that remains. His performances, recordings and former students continue to document a life that stretched well beyond the South Cleveland Street surveillance footage that became central to the prosecution.

Author note: Last updated November 20, 2026.