Authorities spent more than two years moving from uncertain first reports to a final account of the Lilburn killing and its family connections.
LILBURN, Ga. — In the first hours after gunfire erupted inside a Lilburn food store in April 2024, police knew that one woman was dead and two men were wounded, but some of the relationships among them were reported incorrectly. More than two years later, the case ended with a far clearer official record: Teodros Mulat Shibeshi killed his ex-wife’s sister, wounded her brother, survived a self-inflicted gunshot and pleaded guilty to four felony counts before receiving life without parole plus 25 years.
The evolution of the case is significant because the earliest public description did not match the relationships prosecutors ultimately established. Initial reports identified the woman killed as Shibeshi’s former wife and gave an incorrect description of the wounded man’s relationship to her. Investigators revised that information within days after speaking with a relative. Police then identified the dead woman as 57-year-old Tigist Lulesegud and described Shibeshi as her former brother-in-law. When the Gwinnett County District Attorney’s Office announced the final prosecution in October 2026, it stated more specifically that Lulesegud was the sister of Shibeshi’s ex-wife and that the surviving victim, Abebe D. Yeshetela, was her brother.
Those corrections did not change the central fact apparent at the scene: Lulesegud had been shot and killed inside the business. Police responded to Tana Food Mart on Lawrenceville Highway at about 6 p.m. April 27, 2024, according to contemporary reporting. Officers found Lulesegud dead and two men suffering from gunshot wounds. Yeshetela had been struck in the leg. Shibeshi also had been shot. Both men were taken to Northside Hospital Gwinnett, and early reports described Shibeshi as being in critical condition. Investigators quickly determined there was no continuing threat to the public and focused on the relationships among those inside the store.
As detectives reconstructed the event, witness statements supplied the sequence that prosecutors later used in announcing the guilty plea. The district attorney’s office said Shibeshi entered the store while Lulesegud and Yeshetela were working. An altercation followed. Witnesses said Shibeshi shot Lulesegud several times and continued firing after she went down. Prosecutors said he then shot Yeshetela in the leg. The final official account did not describe another assailant or suggest the shootings were random. It characterized the case as a family dispute, consistent with police statements in 2024 that the incident involved domestic violence rather than a threat directed at the general public.
A store customer also described the moments after the two victims were shot. According to the district attorney’s office, the customer told police that Shibeshi made a statement indicating he planned to kill himself. Shibeshi then directed the gun at himself and fired. He survived the wound. The circumstance became part of the public narrative, but authorities did not present it as a substitute for a motive for the shootings of Lulesegud and Yeshetela. Police did not release a specific motive in 2024, and the district attorney’s final 2026 announcement likewise did not explain what prompted Shibeshi to go to the business or what caused the argument to become violent.
The investigation moved into a criminal case once Shibeshi was medically able to leave the hospital. By April 30, 2024, Lilburn police said he faced murder and aggravated-assault charges and was expected to be booked into the Gwinnett County jail. The homicide was the first recorded in Lilburn that year, according to police. At that stage, the case still contained both factual and procedural uncertainties. Detectives had only recently corrected the victims’ relationships to Shibeshi, the full prosecution had not yet been presented in Superior Court, and no court had made a final determination that he was guilty.
Over time, the charges reflected a broader felony prosecution. A 2026 Gwinnett County Superior Court calendar listed Shibeshi on counts of malice murder, felony murder, two counts of aggravated assault and possession of a firearm during the commission of a felony. That record showed the matter remained active as prosecutors prepared for trial. It also provides a snapshot of the case before the final disposition. By the time the district attorney’s office announced the resolution Oct. 2, the plea consisted of malice murder, two aggravated-assault counts and the firearm offense. The office did not separately explain the status of the felony-murder count listed earlier.
The difference between an accusation and a conviction ended with Shibeshi’s guilty plea. Prosecutors said he admitted the offenses before the pending case went to trial. That decision meant jurors did not have to evaluate the witness accounts or determine whether the state had proved its evidence beyond a reasonable doubt. Instead, the plea itself resolved the four counts identified in the district attorney’s announcement. Prosecutors then asked for what they described as the maximum sentence they were seeking: life in prison without the possibility of parole plus 25 years. The judge imposed that punishment.
The sentence is the clearest point at which the two-and-a-half-year progression of the case stops being provisional. Early police reports could be corrected as new information emerged. Charges on a court calendar remained allegations while the prosecution was pending. Witness accounts described what people said they observed. The guilty plea, by contrast, resulted in convictions and a final sentence. Shibeshi is no longer awaiting a determination of guilt for the offenses covered by that plea. He was sentenced to spend life in prison without parole, followed by the additional term announced by prosecutors.
The investigation and prosecution involved several agencies and staff members whose work extended well beyond the initial response at the store. The district attorney’s office said Assistant District Attorney Selwin Patterson prosecuted the case, assisted by Investigator Dennis Hennelly and Victim Witness Advocate Chelsey Thomas. Prosecutors also credited the Lilburn Police Department. The final announcement did not itemize forensic findings or disclose every witness statement gathered during the investigation. Because the case ended before trial, much of that evidence was never presented in open court as part of a contested jury proceeding.
What the completed case does establish is a more reliable account than the one available on the night of the shooting. Lulesegud was not Shibeshi’s former wife; she was the sister of his ex-wife. Yeshetela was identified by prosecutors as Lulesegud’s brother. Both were working at the store when Shibeshi entered. Lulesegud was fatally shot, Yeshetela was wounded and Shibeshi survived after shooting himself. That sequence is supported by the district attorney’s final statement and by contemporary reporting, even though some details — most notably the specific motive and the precise cause of the original altercation — have not been publicly established.
The passage of time also changed how authorities could speak about Shibeshi. In April 2024, police properly described him through the language of an investigation and criminal accusations. The charges had not been adjudicated. In October 2026, after his plea, prosecutors could state that he had admitted the malice murder, both aggravated assaults and the firearm offense. That distinction is important in a case whose early public narrative already required factual correction. The final record is not simply a repetition of the first police report; it reflects later witness interviews, a formal prosecution, court proceedings and Shibeshi’s own decision to plead guilty.
District Attorney Patsy Austin-Gatson marked the resolution with a single public statement focused on the victim’s family. “We hope this outcome can bring justice to Ms. Lulesegud’s family,” she said. Prosecutors did not release statements from surviving relatives or provide a detailed account of Yeshetela’s recovery. The office also did not announce any unresolved criminal charges from the same incident. Its focus was the completed prosecution and the sentence imposed after Shibeshi abandoned the prospect of a trial.
The case is therefore closed on a substantially different footing from the uncertain scene police confronted in April 2024. Authorities corrected mistaken relationship information, identified the surviving victim more precisely, developed felony charges, prepared the prosecution for trial and ultimately obtained Shibeshi’s guilty plea. The motive remains publicly unspecified, but the legal outcome does not: Shibeshi is serving life in prison without the possibility of parole plus 25 years for the killing of Lulesegud, the shooting of Yeshetela and the related firearm offense.
Author note: Last updated November 16, 2026.