A single shell casing, a recovered handgun and witness accounts became part of the murder case that ended with Tara Anderson’s 55-year sentence.
EDWARDSVILLE, Ill. — When Granite City police reached Madison Avenue on the evening of Sept. 24, 2023, they found Phillip Armstrong dead in the roadway and began an investigation that would eventually move through witness interviews, firearm evidence, a jury trial and a contested sentencing hearing. More than three years later, Tara A. Anderson has been sentenced to 55 years in prison for his murder.
The case developed from evidence gathered in the hours and days after Armstrong’s death. Police said one witness had been with the 39-year-old as he tried to retrieve a vehicle near Anderson’s home in the 1400 block of Madison Avenue. The witness reported that Anderson came outside and yelled at Armstrong, then moved back toward the residence. A single gunshot followed. Another witness told investigators that Anderson emerged from the house with a firearm and made a statement that she intended to kill Armstrong. Those accounts gave investigators a sequence to compare with the physical evidence collected around the property.
Police reported finding a .45-caliber shell casing on Anderson’s porch. Investigators later recovered a .45-caliber handgun in the basement of the home and said Anderson’s fingerprint was found on the magazine. Authorities initially described Anderson and Armstrong as having been in a dating relationship and called the shooting an isolated domestic incident. Anderson, then reported as 37, was arrested and charged with murder as well as firearm offenses. The early case established the basic facts of the shooting, but the question that would eventually dominate the trial was not whether Anderson had fired the weapon. It was what she intended when she did so.
Prosecutors later reconstructed the encounter in greater detail. They said Armstrong had gone to Anderson’s residence because she asked him to pick up a vehicle. He was trying to load it onto a trailer when Anderson confronted him. According to the evidence presented at trial, Anderson returned inside her home, got a .45-caliber handgun and came back out. She fired toward Armstrong from roughly 100 feet away. A wooden privacy fence stood between them. The bullet passed through the fence and struck Armstrong. He died at the scene. That physical path became important because Anderson would later characterize the gunfire as a warning rather than an effort to hit him.
The state built its intent argument around more than the trajectory of the shot. Assistant State’s Attorneys Morgan Hudson and Lauren Maricle presented testimony that Anderson had previously told people she wanted Armstrong dead. Prosecutors said she made another threat minutes before the shooting, telling someone in her home that she was going to kill him. Hudson used those statements in closing arguments to contend that the fatal shot followed an expressed intention rather than an accidental turn of events. The prosecution also emphasized that Armstrong had come to the property at Anderson’s request, undermining the idea that she unexpectedly needed to frighten him away.
Defense attorney David Fahrenkamp did not have to persuade jurors that someone else had fired the gun. Anderson testified and acknowledged taking the shot. Instead, the defense asked jurors to distinguish between intentionally discharging a weapon and intentionally killing Armstrong. Anderson said she meant to fire a warning shot to scare him. The defense maintained that the bullet’s fatal result did not reflect her purpose when she pulled the trigger. Prosecutors argued the surrounding evidence — including the threats, the direction of the shot and Armstrong’s known location — supported the opposite conclusion. On May 14, 2026, jurors convicted Anderson of first-degree murder after deliberating a little more than three hours.
That verdict moved the case from evidence of guilt to evidence relevant to punishment. Before sentencing, Fahrenkamp asked Circuit Judge Amy Maher for a new trial. Maher denied the request. The prosecution then argued for a sentence of more than 55 years, while the defense sought 45. Hudson told the judge Anderson’s record included two felony drug convictions, multiple battery charges and numerous orders of protection. She also said Anderson had fired at Armstrong on an earlier occasion and had previously fired at another former boyfriend. Prosecutors presented those circumstances as aggravating factors showing that the fatal shooting did not stand alone in Anderson’s history.
The defense offered a sharply different sentencing narrative. Fahrenkamp said Anderson had endured a difficult life beginning in childhood and told the court she had experienced post-traumatic stress disorder and other problems. He argued that 45 years already represented an extraordinary punishment, noting that Anderson would be an elderly woman before she could leave prison even under the sentence he sought. The defense’s request did not erase the conviction or the jury’s rejection of the warning-shot theory. Instead, it asked Maher to separate the seriousness of the crime from the question of whether Anderson’s history and circumstances justified adding still more years.
The court also heard from the people for whom the evidence represented more than a criminal case. Patrick Armstrong, the victim’s identical twin brother, submitted a statement describing his brother as kind and loving. Armstrong’s daughter, who had been 10 when her father was killed, was 13 by the time Anderson was sentenced. She told the court that her father’s death had changed her life and that future milestones would be reminders of what she had lost. Her statement reflected the passage of time in a prosecution that began with emergency vehicles on Madison Avenue and ended more than three years later in a courtroom.
Anderson spoke before Maher announced the punishment. She apologized and said she never meant for what happened to occur. The statement was consistent with her trial position that the fatal outcome had not been intended. Maher nevertheless had a jury verdict establishing first-degree murder and a sentencing record that included both aggravating and mitigating arguments. She imposed 30 years for the murder and another 25 years based on the use of a firearm. The resulting 55-year term exceeded what the defense requested but did not go as far as prosecutors had urged.
Local reporting said Anderson must serve the entire sentence. That detail gives the Oct. 6 judgment consequences extending far beyond the three-year prosecution that preceded it. The firearm enhancement alone accounts for 25 years of the punishment, while the underlying murder term accounts for 30. The combined sentence reflects both the jury’s determination about Anderson’s intent and the additional punishment attached to using a gun in the killing. State’s Attorney Tom Haine said after sentencing that the case demonstrated the consequences of gun violence and credited Granite City police and the prosecution team for following the evidence through trial.
The progression of the case also shows how early investigative details were later used for a different purpose before jurors. A shell casing that helped establish where a shot was fired became part of a larger story about Anderson’s actions. Witness accounts that initially guided police became evidence about what was said and done moments before Armstrong died. The recovered firearm linked the shooting investigation to the weapon at issue. By trial, those separate facts were no longer isolated pieces of a police file. Prosecutors used them together to argue that Anderson knowingly fired toward a man she had threatened and knew was nearby.
Anderson’s warning-shot explanation remained the competing interpretation through the end of the case. It was presented to jurors, raised again by the defense at sentencing and echoed when Anderson said she had not meant for Armstrong to die. But the jury’s first-degree murder verdict established that the defense had not created reasonable doubt about criminal responsibility. Maher’s 55-year sentence then fixed the consequence of that verdict. The reports reviewed for this article did not identify any later order altering the sentence.
What began with a report of a person shot on a Granite City roadway is therefore no longer an unresolved homicide investigation or a pending murder accusation. Armstrong’s death resulted in a conviction after trial, and Anderson has received the prison term that followed it. The evidence collected in September 2023 has completed its path through the trial court, from police investigation to jury verdict to sentencing judgment.
Author note: Last updated November 18, 2026.