Ex-cop guns down girlfriend’s new man then torches motorcycle shop

Otto Lenke’s sentencing followed a 2021 arrest, years of pretrial proceedings, a May conviction and an 11-1 jury recommendation for execution.

FORT PIERCE, Fla. — What began on a February morning in 2021 as a fire call at a Fort Pierce motorcycle shop became a five-year capital murder case that reached its most consequential judgment Oct. 14, when a judge sentenced former police officer and firefighter Otto Lenke to death.

The sentence came after a legal process that unfolded in distinct stages. Richard Benson, 57, was found dead at Fast Frank’s Cycle Concepts on Feb. 17, 2021. Lenke was arrested within days. For years the prosecution remained pending in St. Lucie County before a jury was selected in 2026. Jurors convicted Lenke on May 8 of first-degree murder with a firearm and first-degree arson. They returned later that month for a separate penalty proceeding and voted 11-1 to recommend execution. Circuit Judge Michael Linn then considered the jury’s findings and the evidence before imposing the death sentence in October. The next stage will take place in Florida’s appellate courts rather than before another trial jury.

At the start, the public knew far less about the case than jurors eventually would. Fire crews responding shortly after 9 a.m. on Feb. 17 found Benson inside the burning business in the 800 block of South Third Street. He had been shot three times, and investigators discovered spent cartridge casings and containers associated with the fire. Fast Frank’s stood near the Fort Pierce Police Department, making the location unusually close to law enforcement. Friends who spoke to reporters after Benson’s death described him as a well-known motorcycle mechanic who helped customers and was generous with people who could not always afford extensive repairs.

Within about 48 hours, investigators had focused on Lenke, then a former Melbourne police officer and retired Indian River County fire-rescue worker. Early court filings revealed only limited information because prosecutors moved to restrict access to probable-cause affidavits while the investigation continued. They argued that releasing the material could interfere with efforts to identify or prosecute other possible participants. Lenke was arrested on first-degree murder and arson charges and held without bond. As more records later became available, they showed why detectives had moved toward him so quickly: surveillance video, a witness identification and vehicle evidence had begun to converge.

The shop’s surveillance system became one of the defining features of the prosecution. Cameras recorded a helmeted person entering the business and the events that followed. Benson’s girlfriend, who knew Lenke, told investigators she recognized him despite the covered face. She cited his walk and the type of motorcycle helmet he wore. Other cameras helped investigators track a Pontiac Bonneville associated with Lenke toward the shop. The vehicle was shown without a license plate during the trip. Court records later said Lenke had removed the tag before traveling approximately 40 minutes to Fort Pierce and had parked away from the storefront before approaching the business.

By the time of trial, prosecutors were able to present those facts not only as identification evidence but as proof of planning. The sentencing order said Lenke waited in the area for roughly 20 minutes, then put on gloves and a motorcycle helmet with a tinted shield. He carried a handgun, two lighters and two containers of denatured alcohol into the shop. Benson was working near the front after arriving to open the business. Surveillance video recorded the attack and Benson’s attempts to reach the front entrance. Lenke shot him three times and started a fire before leaving. Emergency crews later pronounced Benson dead at 9:21 a.m.

The state also presented evidence intended to explain why Lenke targeted Benson. Benson was dating a woman who had previously had a romantic relationship with Lenke and had remained his friend. Court records said that earlier relationship was no longer romantic at the time of the murder. Roughly a month before Benson died, Lenke delivered a boat he had built to the woman. During that visit, Benson called her. According to the sentencing order, Lenke saw Benson’s name on her phone and became emotional, questioning why she did not love him and whether she was seeing someone. Prosecutors later characterized jealousy as the motive, while relying on physical and digital evidence to prove the homicide itself.

Investigators kept building the case after Lenke’s arrest. Court records said his cellphone had remained at his residence while Benson was killed, a fact prosecutors considered alongside other apparent efforts to avoid detection. Investigators later traced movements involving Lenke to his hobby shop, a canal and a shoreline area near the Indian River Lagoon. Part of a Glock firearm recovered from the lagoon area was consistent with the murder weapon. The available record did not establish who had originally acquired that gun secondhand. The prosecution’s case therefore developed as a combination of surveillance footage, witness recognition, vehicle records, recovered evidence and the sequence of Lenke’s movements.

Years passed before jurors heard the evidence. When the trial opened in May 2026, prosecutors showed the surveillance recording and argued that the homicide had been planned in advance. Lenke did not testify in his own defense, according to local reporting. On May 8, the jury convicted him of both charged offenses. That verdict answered the question of criminal responsibility, but because prosecutors were seeking capital punishment, it did not end the jury’s work. The same panel returned for a penalty phase in which the state sought to prove aggravating circumstances and the defense asked jurors to recommend life in prison without parole.

The penalty decision required a different legal judgment from the guilty verdict. Jurors found three aggravating circumstances: that the killing was especially heinous, atrocious or cruel; that it was cold, calculated and premeditated; and that it happened during another felony, the arson. Florida law required at least eight jurors to recommend death before the judge could consider imposing it. On May 21, after about five hours of deliberation, the panel voted 11-1 for execution. Lenke showed no reported reaction as the recommendation was announced. The vote placed the final sentencing choice with Linn.

Nearly five months later, Linn announced his decision at the St. Lucie County Courthouse. The judge’s written findings emphasized the advance preparation and the evidence that Benson was repeatedly prevented from escaping. Linn concluded that the state’s aggravating circumstances outweighed the mitigation and imposed death for the murder. Lenke also faced a prison sentence for first-degree arson. The ruling completed the trial judge’s responsibilities after a process that had begun when investigators first entered the burned motorcycle shop more than five years earlier.

Lenke’s history in public service formed an unusual backdrop to that progression. He served as a Melbourne police officer from 1980 to 1995 and later worked for Indian River County Fire Rescue until 2016. After sentencing, prosecutor Brandon White argued that Lenke had used knowledge gained through law enforcement while planning the crime. The state pointed to the removed license plate, concealed appearance and other precautions. Those measures became part of the evidence of premeditation even though they did not prevent investigators from identifying Lenke.

The October sentence also does not close the case in a legal sense. Florida requires automatic Supreme Court review of death sentences, allowing the state’s highest court to examine the conviction, trial record and capital punishment decision. Lenke is therefore under a death sentence, but no execution date has been set. The case that moved from a fire scene in 2021 to a conviction and sentencing courtroom in 2026 now enters a new phase, with appellate judges responsible for reviewing whether the judgment against him should stand.

Author note: Last updated Nov. 21, 2026.