The family of Jason Similien says warning signs preceded his death, while a former caregiver now faces an aggravated manslaughter charge.
FORT LAUDERDALE, Fla. — The prosecution of former caregiver Jimmy Alexis is only one part of the legal fallout from Jason Similien’s death at a Fort Lauderdale group home, where the 26-year-old’s family says concerns about the employee had been raised before an overnight encounter that police now describe as fatal.
Alexis, 43, was arrested in October 2026 on a charge of aggravated manslaughter of a disabled adult, more than three years after Similien died at Genuine Love and Care Group Home. Similien’s family is also pursuing civil claims tied to his care, shifting part of the focus beyond the alleged conduct of one employee to questions about staffing, supervision and whether earlier concerns should have produced action. The criminal and civil proceedings are separate, however, and allegations made in either case are not findings of wrongdoing in the other.
Adam Finkel, an attorney representing Similien’s family, has said other employees previously complained about Alexis and that Alexis was not fired because of those concerns. Finkel argues that the residential program should have been equipped to understand Similien’s needs and manage his behavior safely. NBC 6 reported that it contacted representatives of the facility and their attorneys after Alexis’ arrest but had not received a response at the time. The family’s claims about what the home knew and how it responded remain matters for the civil process unless established through evidence and court findings.
Similien lived at the facility with significant support needs. Investigators were told he had autism and experienced anxiety and psychosis. Facility representatives also said he could engage in self-injurious behavior, including banging his head against surfaces. Those details became relevant after he was found unresponsive on June 30, 2023, because investigators had to determine whether his death resulted from his own behavior, an accident, actions by a caregiver or some other cause. The medical examiner later classified the death as a homicide, prompting continued scrutiny of what occurred inside the home during the overnight shift.
According to police, another employee supplied the account that ultimately focused the investigation on Alexis. Officers described the woman as visibly shaken during their initial response. She later waited outside and asked to speak away from the facility, according to records cited by Local 10. She told police she had witnessed Alexis choke Similien unconscious twice. The employee said she had warned Alexis during the first incident that he was hurting Similien, and she recorded audio when she saw a second encounter later in the morning. Investigators said Similien could be heard moaning on that recording.
The first confrontation described by the witness occurred about 1 a.m. She said Similien was awake and walking around the residence when Alexis directed him to return to bed. Police records say Similien did not comply. The witness alleged that Alexis placed an arm around Similien’s neck as he sat on a blue foam mat and held him until he lost consciousness. Alexis has disputed the characterization of his actions as choking. He told investigators that he had to restrain Similien at times and later described using what he called “vertical immobilization” several times during the night.
Similien regained consciousness and was moving about the home again around 3 a.m., according to the witness account. He went to a snack closet looking for a cookie. Police said the employee described Alexis as becoming frustrated before allegedly putting Similien in another hold around the neck. The witness said Similien again became unconscious. Finkel has emphasized the ordinary nature of what Similien was doing immediately before that alleged encounter, saying the young man had simply been looking for cookies. Police, however, must prove the charged conduct through evidence rather than through the family attorney’s characterization of events.
Alexis told investigators that his interactions with Similien were prompted by behavior he believed could disturb other residents. He acknowledged restraining Similien four or five times but denied choking him, according to the records. Alexis said Similien later went to bed on his own around 5 a.m. and appeared to sleep. He said he tried to wake him at about 6:45 a.m. and found him unresponsive. Rescue crews responded, and Similien was taken to a hospital, where he was pronounced dead at 7:42 a.m. The witness, by contrast, told police that Similien did not regain consciousness after the second alleged choking.
The investigation extended beyond those two versions. Police arranged for the witness to make a controlled phone call to Alexis. According to the arrest form, investigators heard Alexis describe what he planned to tell authorities and advise the woman to give the same account in her own words. Police said he warned her not to discuss the group home’s logbook, not to mention the mat and not to provide too many details that could lead to further questioning. Those statements are part of the state’s evidence but have not yet been evaluated by a jury, and the defense can challenge their meaning and context.
The medical examiner classified Similien’s death as a homicide in November 2023, several months after he died. An arrest still did not occur for nearly three additional years. Fort Lauderdale police said detectives continued working with the Broward State Attorney’s Office before obtaining the warrant executed on Oct. 6, 2026. Alexis’ attorney questioned the delay when the case reached court and said the allegations appeared to have surfaced unexpectedly after years had passed. Alexis has denied wrongdoing and is entitled to the presumption of innocence as the prosecution proceeds.
The family’s civil litigation addresses a different legal question: whether the entities and people responsible for Similien’s care met their duties to him. Separate federal court records also show an insurance dispute involving Genuine Love and Care LLC and representatives of Similien’s estate, illustrating that the death has generated legal issues beyond the criminal case. That insurance proceeding should not be confused with the manslaughter prosecution or treated as proof of negligence. Its existence reflects disputes over legal and financial responsibility that can arise alongside a wrongful-death or negligence claim.
For Similien’s relatives, Finkel has framed the case around what they believe should have happened before the fatal morning. He has said the home knew Similien’s history and needs and claims there were warning signs involving Alexis. At the same time, the publicly available criminal records reviewed by news organizations focus more narrowly on the overnight events, the witness statement, the recordings, Alexis’ account and the medical examiner’s findings. Whether alleged earlier complaints can be substantiated, who received them and what response they required are issues that may be developed more fully through civil discovery or other court proceedings.
The facility itself has not been criminally charged in the reports reviewed for this article, and police have not publicly established that owners or managers participated in the alleged physical encounters. That distinction is important. A criminal prosecution asks whether Alexis committed the charged offense beyond a reasonable doubt. Civil claims can address broader questions of negligence, supervision and institutional responsibility under a different standard of proof. Evidence may overlap, but a finding in one proceeding does not automatically answer every question raised in another.
Beyond the prosecution of Alexis, Similien’s death continues to raise separate questions about the care he received and what the group home knew before his final shift. Those issues are being pursued through civil litigation under standards different from the criminal case. Alexis has denied the manslaughter allegation, and publicly available reporting through Nov. 18 does not show a final outcome in either track.
Author note: Last updated November 18, 2026.