Deputies say Texas woman shot both her sons inside their home

Authorities say evidence links a Waxahachie woman to her sons’ fatal shootings, but a key question about the case remains unanswered.

WAXAHACHIE, Texas — More than a month after two brothers were fatally shot inside their Waxahachie home, authorities’ public account identifies their mother as the accused shooter and describes evidence supporting her arrest, but it still does not explain why investigators believe the killings occurred.

Colleen Nichole Lemmon, 42, faces two counts of capital murder in the Oct. 1 deaths of her sons, Christopher Scott Pitre, 21, and a 15-year-old boy later identified publicly by family through local reporting as Brian Pitre. The Ellis County Sheriff’s Office said detectives developed probable cause through corroborating evidence recovered during the investigation. Later reports citing an arrest document added an alleged admission and details about a firearm at the scene. Yet neither the Sheriff’s Office nor the subsequent reliable reporting reviewed for this story supplied a verified motive.

That unanswered question separates what investigators say they can establish about responsibility from what they have disclosed about cause. A criminal investigation can produce evidence identifying a suspect without immediately producing a public explanation of motive. In this case, authorities have not said that a dispute, threat, financial issue or other specific event preceded the shootings. No reliable source reviewed for this article established one. Any attempt to fill that gap with speculation about Lemmon, the victims or the family’s private life would go beyond the released evidence.

The criminal allegations themselves remain unresolved. Lemmon was booked into the Wayne McCollum Detention Center after receiving treatment for injuries that authorities said were not life-threatening. Initial coverage said a bond decision was pending. Updated jail-record reporting later listed her bond at $2.5 million. She is accused of two capital murder offenses, but no conviction or final disposition had been identified in reliable public reporting located through Nov. 16. The charges describe the state’s accusation, not a determination that she is guilty.

The evidence described publicly begins with the emergency response. Ellis County deputies were dispatched about 4:13 a.m. Oct. 1 to the 900 block of Big Sky Drive. The Sheriff’s Office characterized the call as an unknown emergency. NBC 5 later reported, citing a probable cause narrative, that dispatchers had received a 911 hang-up and then re-established contact with a female caller. The caller reportedly said all units were needed but did not give dispatchers a clear account of what was happening before the connection ended.

Deputies arriving at the residence found a situation far more serious than the sparse call information had revealed. Inside were two brothers suffering from gunshot wounds. Christopher, 21, was pronounced dead at the scene. His 15-year-old brother was transported to a hospital in critical condition and later died. Lemmon was also present and injured. The Sheriff’s Office said her injuries were not life-threatening. Authorities did not report another wounded person or publicly identify another suspect in connection with the two deaths.

Reports based on the probable cause documentation then provided the allegation most directly connecting Lemmon to the shootings. FOX 4 reported that deputies found her with blood on her and a firearm nearby. When officers asked about the blood, she allegedly said, “I shot both my kids.” Reporting on the document also described what investigators believed were self-inflicted injuries. Those details may be significant evidence for prosecutors, but they remain part of an accusation that can be challenged in court rather than facts established by a verdict.

The Sheriff’s Office used broader language when announcing the arrest. Investigators had developed probable cause through corroborating evidence recovered during the investigation, the agency said. It did not publicly provide a complete list of the evidence, detailed forensic findings or a reconstruction of the shootings. The phrase “corroborating evidence” indicates that investigators say their conclusion rested on more than a single assertion, but the public information available does not show every component of the case prosecutors may ultimately present.

The case also illustrates how early reports can change as an investigation moves from emergency response to booking and court processing. Initial stories said Lemmon’s bond was awaiting determination. Later reports citing jail records placed it at $2.5 million. The younger victim was initially identified only by his age because the Sheriff’s Office withheld his name. NBC 5 later reported that his family identified him as Brian. Those changes do not amount to contradictions in the core case; they reflect information becoming public at different stages.

Other elements have remained consistent from the first reports. The shooting occurred early Oct. 1 at the Big Sky Drive residence. Christopher was dead when first responders reached him. His younger brother survived long enough to be transported to a hospital but later died. Lemmon was found at the home with non-life-threatening injuries and subsequently taken into custody. Authorities identified both victims as her sons and charged her with two counts of capital murder after detectives said the evidence established probable cause.

The boys’ father, Scott Pitre, later added personal context that police records could not provide. NBC 5 reported that he said the younger boy had recently celebrated his 15th birthday at a lake with family. After both sons were killed, he said he wanted justice. His remarks did not attempt to explain the shootings, and authorities have not attributed a motive to him or said that he was present when the violence occurred. The Sheriff’s Office said he was notified of both deaths.

People living near the home expressed shock as the allegations became public. FOX 4 reported that a neighbor described the deaths as heartbreaking and offered prayers for the family. Sheriff Brad Norman likewise issued a statement expressing sympathy to the victims’ father, relatives and loved ones. Neither the neighbor’s comments nor the sheriff’s statement supplied information about what may have led to the shootings. Instead, they underscored how little was known publicly about the events preceding the emergency call.

The lack of a public motive does not erase the evidence investigators say they have, but it places a limit on how the case can accurately be described. Investigators have said who they accuse, what charges were filed, where the victims were found and what happened to them. Reports citing the probable cause narrative describe an alleged statement and physical evidence. What authorities have not established publicly is the reason. Until prosecutors or investigators release reliable information on that issue, it remains unknown.

It also remains unclear from the reliable public reporting located for this article what additional court proceedings have occurred since Lemmon’s initial booking. No later verified report found through Nov. 16 announced a trial result, dismissal, plea or other final resolution. Public reporting similarly did not identify a defense account explaining the shootings. That means the most responsible description of the case is necessarily provisional: authorities have accused Lemmon and say evidence supports the charges, while the judicial process has not produced a final judgment.

One major gap in the public record remains unchanged: investigators have not said what they believe led to the shootings. Lemmon is accused of killing both sons, and authorities say evidence supports those charges, but the reason behind the alleged violence has not been publicly established. Until additional verified evidence or court proceedings supply that answer, motive remains the central unresolved question surrounding the case.

Author note: Last updated November 16, 2026.