Jaymon Trey Gilreath faces a murder accusation supported by police accounts of witnesses, a 911 call, surveillance footage and a recovered handgun.
BLOOMINGTON, Ind. — Jaymon Trey Gilreath’s not-guilty plea has shifted the fatal shooting of Noah Slinkard from a fast-moving police investigation into a criminal case where prosecutors must prove, rather than simply allege, what happened on a Bloomington porch the night of Oct. 8.
The distinction is central to the case against Gilreath, 23. Police and a probable-cause affidavit describe substantial evidence that investigators say links him to Slinkard’s death, including an eyewitness to the shooting, a 911 call in which Gilreath allegedly acknowledged shooting someone, statements from three people who had been traveling with him, a recovered handgun and surveillance footage. Those materials supported a murder charge. They do not constitute a conviction, and Gilreath’s Oct. 12 plea requires the state to prove its case under the higher standard used in criminal proceedings.
Gilreath appeared at his preliminary hearing four days after the shooting. Indiana Public Media reported that he spoke softly during the proceeding and asked Court Commissioner Bret Raper whether he could leave jail and stay with his mother and children. Gilreath referred to his lack of prior felonies and said it was the first time he had done anything like what was alleged. Raper told him he was not eligible for bond in the murder case at that point. When Gilreath expressed uncertainty about his right to remain silent, a public defender explained that the commissioner could not provide him with legal advice.
By the time of that hearing, police had already assembled the chronology used to support the charge. Officers said they received multiple calls at about 8:15 p.m. reporting a shooting at a residence in the 1000 block of North Illinois Street. Callers said a man had been shot and that the suspected shooter was walking east on West 13th Street. Officers found Slinkard, 24, near the front entrance or porch area with a gunshot wound to the head. He was taken by ambulance to IU Health Bloomington Hospital and pronounced dead at 9:49 p.m.
The person sitting on the porch with Slinkard gave police the account that most directly describes the alleged shooting. According to investigators, the witness said Gilreath approached the porch on foot, pulled a handgun from his waist and shot Slinkard before turning and walking away. Police located Gilreath at 8:23 p.m. and took him into custody without incident. That meant the arrest occurred only about eight minutes after the initial reports, before authorities had completed the broader work of collecting statements and physical evidence.
The investigation expanded along the route Gilreath was believed to have taken after leaving the residence. Police found a 9 mm handgun inside a holster near a park bench in the 1300 block of West 13th Street, beside Crestmont Park. Authorities said they believed it was the weapon used in the shooting. Reporting on the court affidavit says Gilreath later told officers where he had discarded the firearm. Public accounts reviewed for this story have not disclosed a complete ballistics or forensic report, so any laboratory findings involving the gun remain outside the confirmed public record available here.
Police also attributed an important statement to Gilreath before detectives questioned him at length. While officers were responding, the affidavit says, Gilreath called 911 and told a dispatcher that he had just shot someone. A reported admission can become significant evidence, but its precise context can matter in court. Defense attorneys may review the complete recording, circumstances of the call and wording used, while prosecutors may argue it corroborates what the porch witness and other evidence show. The publicly available reports summarize the call but do not reproduce a full transcript.
Another part of the affidavit addresses events before the gunfire and what investigators describe as a possible motive. Gilreath reportedly told detectives that he had a child with a former partner and that they had planned to spend time together that day. When she did not arrive or answer calls and messages, he became suspicious, according to the filing. Gilreath said he had a “gut feeling” that she was cheating on him with Slinkard. Later, while riding with friends, he saw her vehicle and then saw Slinkard outside a residence, investigators said.
The three people in the vehicle provided police with statements about Gilreath’s conduct after he saw Slinkard. According to the affidavit, they said Gilreath wanted to get out and told them he planned to fight Slinkard. They also recalled him making a statement to the effect that they should leave if they heard a gunshot. The witnesses said they heard a shot soon afterward. Those statements could be used by prosecutors to describe Gilreath’s actions before the shooting, but the defense is entitled to examine the witnesses about what they remember, how their statements were taken and whether their accounts changed.
Gilreath’s reported interview with detectives introduces another issue likely to receive scrutiny. He gave investigators an account of seeing his former partner’s vehicle, noticing Slinkard and going toward the residence, but he reportedly said he did not specifically remember the shooting. The affidavit says his next memory was leaving and realizing that he was holding his gun with the safety off, which led him to realize he had shot Slinkard. Police say nearby cameras independently recorded Gilreath shooting Slinkard and leaving. The footage itself has not been publicly aired in the reports reviewed for this update.
The court process gives both sides an opportunity to test those different pieces of evidence in ways that a police news release does not. Prosecutors may seek to introduce witness testimony, recordings, Gilreath’s statements and physical evidence. Defense counsel may challenge admissibility, reliability, identification, interpretation or the state’s claimed proof of intent. The judge may also have to decide pretrial evidentiary issues before any jury hears the case. No such future ruling should be assumed from the probable-cause filing, and the available reporting does not establish what motions the defense may bring.
Investigators’ description of a suspected romantic relationship also requires careful treatment. Police said witnesses told them Gilreath believed Slinkard was involved with his former girlfriend, and Gilreath allegedly described the same suspicion in his interview. That belief is relevant to investigators’ theory of why he approached the porch. The reviewed sources, however, do not independently establish that Slinkard and the woman were in a romantic relationship. The distinction matters because the case can accurately report what Gilreath allegedly believed without treating that belief as a proven fact about Slinkard.
Slinkard’s death, meanwhile, is not disputed in the public record. The Monroe County Coroner’s Office identified him after the shooting, and police said he died at the hospital at 9:49 p.m. What remains disputed in court is Gilreath’s criminal liability and the legal interpretation of the evidence gathered afterward. A murder charge carries grave consequences, but the filing of that charge does not remove the presumption of innocence. Gilreath remains entitled to require prosecutors to meet their burden in court.
Initial reports scheduled a bond review for Oct. 27 and a pretrial conference for Nov. 18. Both dates have passed, but reliable publicly indexed reporting located through Nov. 20 did not confirm the results of those proceedings, identify a later trial date or report a final resolution. The last independently confirmed plea in the available coverage is not guilty. Unless and until a court reaches a different disposition, the case remains an unresolved murder prosecution.
Author note: Last updated Nov. 20, 2026.