College student allegedly attacks music instructor he blamed for making him work

Investigators say Alexander William Cusey described planning and carrying out the attack, while his statements remain allegations subject to court scrutiny.

MORRIS, Minn. — Much of the public account of an alleged attempt to kill a University of Minnesota Morris percussion instructor comes not from eyewitnesses to the attack but from statements prosecutors say the accused student made afterward to a doctor and police.

Alexander William Cusey, 21, faces attempted first-degree premeditated murder and three assault charges over the Sept. 29 stabbing inside the university’s Humanities and Fine Arts building. The criminal complaint describes physical evidence and the instructor’s injuries, but it also relies heavily on what Cusey allegedly said after his arrest about preparation, intent and his conduct during the encounter. Those statements have generated attention because of their disturbing content. Legally, however, they remain part of the prosecution’s allegations unless and until they are admitted and weighed through the court process.

The first reported statements came while Cusey was receiving medical care for a cut to a finger. According to the complaint, a doctor reported that Cusey said he had been trying to kill his percussion instructor. He also allegedly said he had tried to stab the instructor in the neck and heart but the instructor avoided those blows. The instructor nevertheless suffered stab wounds to an arm and two or three cuts to the right side of his head, court-based reports say. Both men were taken for medical treatment after officers arrested Cusey at the arts building.

Investigators then conducted a recorded interview that expanded the account beyond the hospital remarks. Cusey allegedly told an officer that he had bought the knife the previous day because he planned to kill the instructor. He described being in the practice room first, holding his percussion mallets and trying to appear normal, according to the complaint. When the instructor turned to open a bag, prosecutors say, Cusey drew the knife and began the attack. The allegation that the weapon was obtained in advance is one of the clearest facts prosecutors cite in support of their claim of premeditation.

Other alleged comments concerned Cusey’s feelings about the instructor. According to reports on the complaint, he called the instructor a “goodie two shoes” and complained that he gave him work to do. Cusey also allegedly told police that he did not want to attend college or get a job and suggested prison would be one way to avoid that future. Those comments may be relevant to investigators’ effort to understand the attack, but they should not be treated as a complete or proven motive. The available court reporting does not establish a judicial finding explaining why the stabbing occurred.

The complaint attributes additional disturbing remarks to Cusey about his reaction during the attack. Investigators said he characterized the experience as exciting and described responding with amusement while the instructor pleaded for him to stop. Law&Crime reported further alleged statements in which Cusey talked about having a “monster” inside him and made comments about violent impulses. Such language is notable because it came from the accused person, according to police, but it does not amount to a professional diagnosis or establish a medical condition. The public records reviewed do not provide a clinical assessment explaining his behavior.

Investigators also said Cusey discussed violent fantasies involving relatives and a possible school shooting if he had access to a gun. Those allegations are serious, but the reports reviewed do not say that he was charged with carrying out those other acts. They are described as statements made during an interview after the instructor stabbing. Separating the charged conduct from uncharged statements is important in a criminal case: the four filed counts concern the attack on the percussion instructor, not every disturbing idea or assertion prosecutors say surfaced during Cusey’s interview.

Physical events at the university provide a separate track of evidence. Public safety officers were dispatched at about 4:02 p.m. after receiving a report of a stabbing. In the lower level of the Humanities and Fine Arts building, an officer encountered a staff member holding closed a door leading to several small music practice rooms. The staff member said the wounded instructor had run into his office, identified Cusey as the attacker and indicated that Cusey remained in the practice-room area. An officer provided a tourniquet for the instructor’s arm while more officers arrived.

Police then called for Cusey to come out with his hands raised. He stepped from a room into the hallway and was taken into custody, according to the complaint. Investigators recovered a knife in a percussion practice room. Those circumstances do not depend on Cusey’s later interview for their basic outline. Together with the instructor’s injuries, they form the physical and witness-based foundation of the case, while the alleged statements address questions such as intent and advance planning that are central to the most serious count.

The instructor’s actions are also significant to the chronology. He survived the attack, left the practice room and sought help from a colleague. According to one account based on the charging document, he told Cusey to call 911 before leaving, and Cusey later said he made that call. The staff member who encountered the injured instructor then helped keep the practice-room hallway closed until police arrived. The reports reviewed do not identify the instructor publicly, and no reliable source consulted for this article states that anyone else was physically injured.

Prosecutors ultimately charged Cusey with attempted first-degree premeditated murder, first-degree assault causing great bodily harm, second-degree assault with a dangerous weapon causing substantial bodily harm and a second count of second-degree assault with a dangerous weapon. MN Crime reported that the attempted-murder charge carries a maximum possible sentence of 20 years. Maximum penalties describe statutory exposure, not the sentence a person will necessarily receive. Cusey is entitled to contest the state’s evidence, including the circumstances and admissibility of any statements attributed to him.

The distinction between an allegation and an established fact is particularly important when a charging document contains inflammatory language. A probable cause statement is written to explain why authorities believe charges are justified. It can include interviews, witness accounts and alleged admissions, but it is not a verdict. Cusey’s reported descriptions of his own thoughts and conduct therefore should be understood as evidence prosecutors may seek to use, not as facts a jury has already accepted. The available sources do not show a final adjudication of the case.

Initial news reports also disagreed about Cusey’s age. Law&Crime listed him as 20, while CBS Minnesota, Valley News Live and Bring Me The News identified him as 21, and a booking record from the period of his arrest also listed 21. This report follows the latter records. There is much less disagreement over the key chronology: the Sept. 29 stabbing, the instructor’s injuries and escape, Cusey’s arrest, recovery of a knife and the filing of four felony counts are consistently reported across the court-based accounts reviewed.

Custody information has changed since the first stories appeared. Early coverage placed Cusey in the Wilkin County Jail. A Douglas County inmate roster available Nov. 18 lists him there with an Oct. 14 booking date under Stevens County authority and shows the same four categories of alleged offenses. The roster is a custody record and does not establish guilt. No later reliable source located for this article showed that the criminal case had reached a conviction, acquittal or other final resolution.

For now, the case remains defined by two kinds of evidence described in the public record: what happened inside and immediately outside the practice room, and what prosecutors say Cusey told people afterward. The first establishes the reported attack and response; the second is central to the state’s claim about planning and intent. As of Nov. 18, those claims remained allegations in an unresolved criminal proceeding, with Cusey still listed in custody.

Author note: Last updated November 18, 2026.