Four other defendants were charged in the same homicide investigation, but Randal Moon Jr. became the first to face sentencing.
MUNCIE, Ind. — Five people were charged as investigators pieced together the killing of Michael D. Greer across Indianapolis, Shelbyville and rural Delaware County. The first of those prosecutions has now produced a prison sentence: Randal Moon Jr., 41, received 86 years after a jury convicted him of murder and four other felonies arising from Greer’s December 2025 death.
Moon’s case is significant not only because of the length of the sentence but because it is the first completed trial among a group of prosecutions built from the same homicide investigation. Judge Judi L. Calhoun sentenced Moon on Oct. 13 after jurors convicted him Sept. 18 of murder, arson resulting in serious bodily injury, kidnapping, obstruction of justice and conspiracy to obstruct justice. Amy Singhas, Ameariss Aponte, Megan Sloan and Tallis McCoy were also charged in connection with Greer’s death. Their cases are legally separate, and evidence accepted by the jury against Moon does not establish the guilt of any other defendant.
Greer, 58, was from Shelbyville, and the investigation initially had to establish who had died before prosecutors could begin sorting out who might be responsible. Shortly before 4 a.m. on Dec. 14, 2025, deputies responded to a burning vehicle in a field along Delaware County Road 500 South west of Indiana 3. Human remains were found in the trunk after authorities examined the car. The vehicle was a rental associated with Greer, but officials later relied on Indiana State Police DNA testing to formally identify him. Sheriff Jeff Stanley announced that identification in January as his department continued working with the Delaware County Coroner’s Office and county prosecutors.
The investigation soon produced a disturbing but important forensic finding. Soot was discovered in Greer’s lungs and trachea during the autopsy. Authorities said that meant he had been breathing when the fire started. Investigators also found evidence that Greer had been beaten and shot before the car was burned. Their reconstruction moved the beginning of the crime away from Delaware County and back to Indianapolis, where they said Greer was assaulted at a residence before being transported. The public record reviewed for this report does not establish a verified motive for the killing, although Greer’s relatives previously said he and Singhas had been in a relationship.
The five defendants entered the case at different times and under different alleged theories of involvement. Moon, Singhas and Aponte were arrested during the earlier stages of the investigation. Sloan and McCoy were charged later as investigators continued conducting interviews and reviewing evidence. Reports on the initial cases said authorities believed Singhas drove the rental car containing Greer from Indianapolis toward the remote Delaware County location. Aponte was accused of later getting behind the wheel and taking the vehicle off the roadway near the field. Moon drove a separate pickup truck. These allegations must be considered separately for defendants whose cases have not resulted in convictions.
Moon’s own statements narrowed the factual dispute in his trial. He acknowledged that he traveled from Indianapolis to Delaware County while Singhas and Aponte were in the rental car. He also acknowledged being at the field and driving the two back to Indianapolis after the rental vehicle was burning. Moon testified, however, that he did not know Greer was in the trunk and did not know a plan existed to set the car on fire. The defense therefore did not ask jurors to believe Moon had never been present. It asked them to distinguish presence and transportation from knowing participation in murder, kidnapping, arson and a cover-up.
Prosecutors tried to erase that distinction by presenting evidence from before and after the fire. Cellphone location information placed Moon at the Indianapolis residence at the time prosecutors said Greer was beaten. A recording recovered in the investigation reportedly showed an assault on Greer, though Moon was not visible in that video. Prosecutors also pointed to Moon’s actions involving Greer’s credit card. Trial reporting said Moon photographed the card on the morning of the killing and later tried to use it for a purchase. Evidence also showed him traveling with Singhas and Aponte to Greer’s Shelbyville home two days after Greer’s death.
The prosecution used Moon’s cellphone activity after the homicide for another purpose: to challenge his claim about what he knew. Prosecutors said records showed that Moon viewed and photographed news coverage about the killing despite statements suggesting he had not known the car fire caused a death. Deputy Prosecutor Maricel Driscoll argued in closing that Moon had been an active participant rather than an accidental witness or driver. Chief Deputy Prosecutor Zach Craig joined in presenting the state’s case. The jury ultimately accepted that theory, returning guilty verdicts after several hours of deliberation at the end of the weeklong September trial.
Moon’s conviction created a clear dividing line within the five-defendant case. Allegations concerning him had been tested before a jury and resulted in guilty verdicts. Allegations concerning the other defendants still had to proceed through their own cases. That distinction is especially important in a prosecution involving claims that several people played different roles at different times. A jury deciding Moon’s case was not deciding whether Singhas, Aponte, Sloan or McCoy should be convicted. The remaining defendants retain the presumption of innocence unless a court record establishes a guilty plea or verdict against them.
The procedural paths of those other cases have not all moved at the same pace. Aponte had a September trial date that was postponed, and reporting around Moon’s sentencing listed an Oct. 28 court appearance. Singhas had been scheduled for trial Nov. 16. Earlier reporting also described a Nov. 16 setting involving Sloan, who had previously been found incompetent to stand trial, making her status dependent on further competency proceedings. McCoy had a jury trial listed for Dec. 14 in the most recent reliable reports. Because some of those dates have now passed, earlier schedules should not be treated as proof that a trial occurred or that a case was resolved.
As of Nov. 20, the reliable public reporting reviewed for this article did not provide a confirmed final result for every proceeding that had been listed after Moon’s sentencing. That leaves Moon as the defendant whose outcome is firmly established in the available record: a Sept. 18 jury conviction followed by Calhoun’s 86-year prison sentence on Oct. 13. If court dates for the other defendants changed, were continued or produced additional rulings, those developments require separate confirmation rather than inference from older schedules.
The unresolved cases also leave broader factual questions open. Authorities have publicly described an alleged chain of events leading from the Indianapolis residence to Delaware County, and Moon’s trial supplied a jury-tested account of his own involvement. But prosecutors have not publicly established a verified motive in the sources reviewed here. Nor does Moon’s conviction answer every question about what each other defendant allegedly did. Those issues belong to the remaining court proceedings, where prosecutors will have to prove the charges applicable to each defendant independently.
For Greer’s relatives, the five separate prosecutions arise from the loss of one person. His obituary described him as devoted to family and friends and remembered his generosity, thoughtful nature and humor. Those personal details contrast with the way his name appears in court records, where his final hours have been reconstructed through autopsy findings, cellphone records, surveillance footage and testimony. Moon’s sentence provides the first final trial-level measure of accountability in the case, but it does not conclude the entire legal process surrounding Greer’s death.
The next confirmed milestones will depend on updated court records for the four unresolved defendants. McCoy’s previously reported Dec. 14 trial date remained the clearest future setting in the sources reviewed, while the status of proceedings previously scheduled for Aponte, Singhas and Sloan requires current confirmation. Moon, meanwhile, faces the 86-year sentence imposed after the jury found him criminally responsible for his part in the events that ended with Greer in the trunk of the burning rental car.
Author note: Last updated November 20, 2026.