The case against Joseph Petrella emerged through a sequence of investigative steps that began at another home on the same street.
PENFIELD, N.Y. — The investigation that ended with Joseph Petrella accused of murdering his mother began at someone else’s home. A neighbor reported a burglary, deputies gathered evidence pointing them toward Petrella, and an encounter at his residence led authorities to find 60-year-old Amy Hogan dead inside.
That progression has become the defining investigative thread in a case now pending in Monroe County Court. Petrella, 39, has pleaded not guilty to second-degree murder, second-degree burglary and petit larceny. Prosecutors allege he stabbed and cut Hogan several times during a confrontation between Sept. 12 and Sept. 13 and then left her body inside the residence they shared. Authorities have not publicly established what caused the confrontation or supplied a motive. Petrella has been held without bail, and the state’s allegations have not been tested at trial.
The first known law enforcement action came at about 3 p.m. Sept. 13. Monroe County sheriff’s deputies were dispatched to Ewald Drive for a burglary report. A resident said someone had gone through a vehicle and entered the home, with property discovered missing afterward. According to reporting based on investigative records, security-camera footage prompted suspicion that Petrella was responsible. Deputies therefore approached him not as a homicide suspect but as part of an inquiry into a reported break-in and theft at a neighboring property.
The next step changed the direction of the case. The sheriff’s office said Petrella granted a deputy access to his residence. Chief Deputy Michael Fowler later explained that once inside, the deputy noticed things that appeared unusual and became concerned. Petrella was detained while deputies continued investigating. The public accounts do not spell out every observation that caused the deputy’s concern, and authorities have not released a minute-by-minute narrative of the encounter. They do agree on what happened next: deputies discovered Hogan dead inside the home.
From that point, the sheriff’s response shifted to a homicide investigation. Deputies secured the residence, and the Major Crimes Unit took the lead. Evidence technicians were called to process the scene. Investigators obtained and executed a search warrant, and a crime victim’s advocate assisted Hogan’s relatives. Those procedural steps matter because much of what the prosecution will ultimately rely on appears to have been gathered after the unexpected discovery. The sheriff’s office later said the evidence collected during the investigation led its Major Crimes Unit to identify Petrella as the suspect in Hogan’s death and arrest him.
A felony complaint subsequently described allegations not included in the sheriff’s initial public announcement. It accused Petrella of stabbing and cutting Hogan multiple times with a sharp object during a confrontation. Deputies found Hogan’s body in a bathtub, wrapped in a plastic shower curtain, according to the complaint. The document said frozen items had been packed around her body, which an investigator interpreted as an apparent attempt to conceal it. That allegation has drawn attention because of the unusual scene deputies encountered, but authorities have not publicly said how long Hogan’s body had been there beyond alleging the killing occurred during the period shortly before the Sept. 13 discovery.
The complaint gives prosecutors a theory of the killing but not a complete motive. Assistant District Attorney Ellie Laloudakis acknowledged that gap after Petrella’s Oct. 7 arraignment in Monroe County Court. She said investigators may never know exactly how events unfolded, what fully led to Hogan’s death or why Petrella allegedly killed her. Prosecutors nevertheless say they believe the stabbing occurred between the night of Sept. 12 and Sept. 13. The distinction between those two points is important: authorities have stated when they believe Hogan died and how she was killed, but they have not claimed to know the full sequence that produced the alleged confrontation.
The burglary investigation remains more than background because it produced two of Petrella’s three charges and explains why deputies were in the neighborhood in the first place. The sheriff’s office charged him with second-degree burglary and petit larceny as well as second-degree murder. Investigators and prosecutors have treated those accusations as part of the same overall case history, though the alleged offenses involve different conduct. The burglary charge concerns unlawful entry into another property, while the larceny charge concerns allegedly stolen property. The murder charge concerns Hogan’s death. Each allegation must be established through evidence in court rather than assumed from the fact of Petrella’s arrest.
Petrella was initially arraigned after his arrest and remanded to the Monroe County Jail without bail. When he appeared in Monroe County Court on Oct. 7, he pleaded not guilty. His attorney declined to comment afterward, according to local reporting. Two orders of protection were also issued in connection with the burglary investigation. The next court appearance was scheduled for Dec. 4. The sources reviewed for this report do not identify a trial date or disclose a defense theory, meaning the case remains at a stage where charging documents and prosecutors’ statements provide the principal public description of the alleged crimes.
The investigation’s procedural path also shows how quickly a police response can change when new evidence emerges. Deputies arrived prepared to investigate reported stolen property. Their inquiry led them to a nearby resident. His permission to enter a home exposed circumstances that concerned a deputy. The discovery inside prompted detention, scene security, a search warrant, evidence processing and a Major Crimes investigation. None of those later steps was the original purpose of the dispatch. The sequence, as described by the sheriff’s office and local court reporting, is therefore central evidence of how authorities came to focus on Petrella rather than merely a dramatic detail surrounding the arrest.
Behind that sequence was Hogan, whose family described a markedly different set of details about her life. Her obituary says she was born in Rochester in 1966 and was a mother of four and grandmother of two. She painted, crocheted, made pottery, sewed, gardened, cooked and worked on other crafts. Relatives wrote that she shared meals and treats freely and put significant energy into birthdays, holidays and family gatherings. They remembered a reader, gardener and enthusiastic card player with close friendships. Her grandchildren occupied a particularly important place in her life, according to the obituary, which recalled sleepovers, games, nature activities, art and family traditions.
Those memories surfaced publicly while the legal case was developing. Hogan’s mother attended Petrella’s October court appearance, according to the prosecutor, and Laloudakis said she had met Hogan’s three daughters. The prosecutor described the family as devastated by the loss. The criminal justice process can determine whether the state proves its accusations against Petrella, but it cannot resolve every unanswered question about the private interaction that prosecutors say preceded Hogan’s death. That limitation is one prosecutors themselves have acknowledged even as they move forward with the murder charge.
What began with a call about missing property has now become a pending homicide prosecution whose outcome will depend on evidence presented in court. Petrella has pleaded not guilty, prosecutors have not announced a motive, and no trial date had been reported. The investigation’s next publicly identified milestone was his Dec. 4 return to Monroe County Court.
Author note: Last updated November 18, 2026.