TUCSON, Ariz. — Nearly three months have passed since 84-year-old Nancy Guthrie vanished from her home in the Catalina Foothills, and her family remains in turmoil as they seek answers in the face of escalating uncertainty. On May 10, her daughter, Savannah Guthrie, shared a heartfelt Instagram tribute on Mother’s Day, showcasing intimate family moments that captured the spirit of the matriarch, whom they affectionately call “Nonie.”
In a poignant 44-second montage, Savannah reflected on joyful memories, expressing the family’s enduring hope to find her mother. “We miss you with every breath,” she wrote, highlighting their relentless search for answers. As of May 11, it will have been 100 days since Nancy was last seen after being dropped off following dinner.
Despite an extensive investigation and a reward totaling $1.2 million, including a significant contribution from the Guthrie family, no suspects have emerged and no arrests have been made. The urgency of the search intensifies as investigators piece together clues from the night Nancy disappeared.
The timeline of her disappearance started when she was reported missing after failing to show up for a neighbor’s online church service the following day. Investigators have uncovered chilling evidence, including a doorbell camera that was turned off shortly before her disappearance and a pacemaker that lost connection with her phone. Blood belonging to Nancy was discovered on her front porch, marking what some experts suggest could have been a struggle.
On February 10, the FBI made public images captured by the doorbell camera, which revealed a masked individual outside Nancy’s home at the time of her disappearance. Although gloves found nearby did not yield DNA matches, the investigation continues with mixed DNA samples under analysis. Authorities believe it is possible more than one person was involved in her case, yet they have not established a clear motive.
Amid community support, a makeshift memorial has formed outside her home, where local residents have expressed solidarity with the Guthrie family. An anonymous letter recently surfaced at the memorial, appealing to the abductor to return Nancy before Mother’s Day. It poignantly invoked the bond between mothers and children.
On the same day she shared her Mother’s Day tribute, Savannah announced on the “Today” show that she would be hosting a new game show based on the popular word game Wordle. The production, which marks her return to television amid personal turmoil, is set to begin filming this summer in Manchester, England.
Although her professional life continues, Savannah admitted to the emotional complexity of her situation. “It’s strange to get up and do the Today show every day,” she shared, emphasizing her determination to keep moving forward despite the deep sorrow overshadowing her life.
Authorities are calling for public assistance in the case. Anyone with relevant information regarding Nancy Guthrie’s disappearance is urged to contact the Pima County Sheriff’s Department or the FBI to help bring closure to this unsettling chapter for a loving family.